Still one of my favorite

While other have valid criticism

I loved the interactions

Kudos to you Manhattan

It's a passable read. It's better than most fanfiction, but that is not really that high of a bar. The grammar is good, scene descriptions, characters, and interactions are mostly okay.
However, this is the most generic crossover one can have, where the inserted characters bring no significant changes to the plot, beyond saving some characters that don't significantly affect anything. The plot is the same as in the movies, all the events that happen there also happen in this fic (sans the character deaths). The Avengers are nerfed to hell, and have no influence on the original plot. Even in the later battles (where their input is the greatest), their participation does not change anything. The battles that are won are still won with heavy casualties, the battles that are lost are still lost. NOTHING is added to LOTR beyond some additional interactions between the Avengers and the Fellowship (which themselves don't lead to anything).
In essence, this is just a worse retelling of the movies with some additional Marvel-themed filler. I've read it in two days and am regretting my life choices.
If you want a good crossover with marvel read something like Soldier Adrift or God Adrift. The second is probably abandoned but first should be updating.

I'm really glad I've decided to look at some of the older fics on this site.
It was great, and I'll add it to my favourites :)

A complete and utter waste of time, dropping in 3 characters from a completely different world and yet not making any changes to the original story is completely and utterly disappointing

If I wanted to read a story that didn't change in any way I would just reach for the books
I really don't know why everyone is so enthusiastic about it

A complete and utter waste of time, dropping in 3 characters from a completely different world and yet not making any changes to the original story is completely and utterly disappointing

If I wanted to read a story that didn't change in any way I would just reach for the books

This was a really good story. Well done.

I like this version of Denethor's death much better than PJ's

This was a very strange chapter. Good but strange...

Souron would absolutely do something like what you had him do though it would be more Sourony in appearance it would be jagged and scream "I am a DArk Lord douchbag and this isn't 40k so no God Emperor to save you now humanity""

I don't know how many time I have read this fanfic, but it's a really really good one. Thank you for all of your work

A truly fantastic work of fiction, I enjoyed every moment of it and really couldn't stop once I started. I wish there was more in the epilogue but I'm glad to hear that Thor and Gandalf met once more. Cheers and great work again.

As I read this story for the like the hundredth time, but I noticed some typos and repetitions in the previous chapter.
Just to let you know!

I love this fanfic so much! I don't remember how many times I have read it again and again !

To me, it's the very example of what a LOTR crossover should be!

the maximum score is 2 out of 10, the characters of the Avengers are just filler, and stories are not needed, they do nothing, their motivation, their motives are also zero, and when any actions occur, the available forces simply disappear, as in the beginning. this is explained in the story by the phrase "because".

boring