|Reviews for Men-i-Naugrim|
| Noxy the Proxy chapter 6 . 1/12
Hmmm, what fun I shall read more!
| Hi chapter 50 . 2/19/2014
The last chapter was so touching and bittersweet.
| Arekkusu Naitofaia chapter 50 . 2/10/2014
...I don't know what to say. I really don't. There are not any words to describe how absolutely perfect this fanfiction was. Not many fanfics can make me cry, trust me, but you had me. Thorin's death had me bawling like a baby. I'll admit I wasn't so sure about this fic at first but wow it just got better and better and I'm so glad I finished it because they dearie is a masterpiece! Best Hobbit fanfic I've read, straight up. Fíli an Kíli were positively adorable and full of my favouritist thing ever: bromance! I'm so glad you didn't kill them and for that I hug you ten million times. Dwalin was so perfect, I think I nearly wet myself laughing at all his lines. Radagast was so adorable. Bilbo was brilliant. Gandalf actually gave a shit about someone other than Thorin and Bilbo! Yay! Bard was brilliant (go Fíli for doing the right thing with Bard), Thrandy is a douchebag...nothing new there but go Legolas for having sense! Also glad about Fíli's way of handling that as well. I love how you intergrated the whole cast of the Hobbit instead of just focusing on a few. The Durin family moments were so precious that thinking about all of them in this fic and then thinking about Thorin's death is just making me cry even more. You did it perfectly. This really is a beautiful fanfiction, Tolkien should learn from this hahahahaha. Tell him not to going killing off the best characters, though I suppose Peter Jackson glorified them into being more likeable (I mean really Richard, Dean and Aidan...he totally chose them to be sexy dwarves so we would feel even worse in the BoFA I don't wanna see the little lion or those puppy eyes fade...) but anyay I digress, thank you so much for writing this because I have enjoyed reading it, I now give you all my Internet cookies! While I continue to cry...it's totally 3:30am...Fíli would have been a great King...
| Robyn chapter 50 . 7/3/2013
Absolutely lovely. You did a fantastic job and I am so glad you didn't kill off Kili and Fili.
| Opal1030 chapter 50 . 6/29/2013
It took me about a week, but I've read all 50 chapters, and all I can say is PHENOMENAL! I laughed, I cried...it was a definite page turner. (Or would that be screen turner?) I loved how you portrayed the relationships between Fili & Kili, Bilbo & the two young dwarf princes, but most of all between Thorin and his nephews. And the detail? ASTOUNDING! You have an amazing talent! I look forward to reading more of your stories in the near future.
| Guest chapter 50 . 6/20/2013
I read this story in a span of four days! It was just beautiful. I could not stop, I had to force myself to take a break for sleep. This story was magnificent. I laughed and cried, then both at the same time. The brothers love for each other touched my heart and when they fought my heart broke for them much like poor bilbo. You did thorins death justice, it was a wonderful ending to a damaged soul. I love that you built up the friendships and they weren't just a company of misfits but eventually a company of brothers. I love the hobbit but I really wish this was the actually story! Smaug was defeated the way he should have been and it was an actual battle, detailed and captivating. I'm glad the boys survived, I'm glad they were given the chance to have long lives instead of being cut down so young. This was a wonderful journey, a fun emotional roller coaster. Thank you for sharing it with me :)
| Arweyn chapter 50 . 3/26/2013
Urgh...this was the most beautiful fanfiction I have ever read. The last few chapters were so sad and happy at the same time, tears sprang in my eyes...I must say, I am in awe for the time you've spent on this fanfiction, but I think it's been worth it. It's wonderfully written and highly detailed. I love how you tweaked things here and there and you let Fili and Kili live...(I'm not sure how I will be able to see the screen at the theaters when the three of them die in the movie) No...don't want to think of that. Thank you so so much for writing this amazing story, and I think you should have won that challenge, because this is downright epic. Thank you again.
(sorry for posting this twice, I wasn't logged in at the moment I wrote this...)
| Guest chapter 50 . 3/26/2013
Urgh...this was the most beautiful fanfiction I have ever read. The last few chapters were so sad and happy at the same time, tears sprang in my eyes...I must say, I am in awe for the time you've spent on this fanfiction, but I think it's been worth it. It's wonderfully written and highly detailed. I love how you tweaked things here and there and you let Fili and Kili live...(I'm not sure how I will be able to see the screen at the theaters when the three of them die in the movie) No...don't want to think of that. Thank you so so much for writing this amazing story, and I think you should have won that challenge, because this is downright epic. Thank you again 3
| harrylee94 chapter 50 . 3/15/2013
Amazing! Amazing story! I loved the flash backs at the end, reminding us all of the fantastic, long and winding road you took us down. Brilliant! I will be hard pressed to forget your tale!
| Niphrehdil chapter 50 . 3/4/2013
Thank you so much for writing this story. the quality was purely amazing. i'm really hoping that you will wrote some more Hobbit fics soon! :)
| Thorny Hedge chapter 23 . 3/4/2013
"It's a nice thing, you know", Kíli said, looking up at the stars above them. "To have a brother. They protect you and keep you warm and teach you everything they know. They take the blame when your mother scolds you, they stand up for you and they know how to beat you up well enough until you learned your lesson. And when you're close to losing them, you're close to losing the most important part of your life and it feels like choking slowly."
| LiL PriNCeSs Me chapter 50 . 3/3/2013
Perfect. That was perfect, nothing less. I'm just at a loss here. This story was just absolutely amazing. It was so emotional and heart felt, you had me crying. Man, that little memory part at the end, genius. This story, in all it's 50 chapters, never ceased to amaze me, or thrill me, or scare me, or leave me with some strong emotion. You are so very talented. I could only wish this is how the real story ends and I just love your interpretation. I don't think I can say anything different then I've already said for you. Again, amazing and brilliant. Thank you so much for this wonderful fic! It's going to be so weird not seeing those alerts in my inbox and I'll probably feel a little empty not waiting for them lol.
| LiL PriNCeSs Me chapter 49 . 3/3/2013
I know the next chapter is the last one, so I don't want to read it but I have to!
| LiL PriNCeSs Me chapter 48 . 3/3/2013
Oh man. I'm so proud of Fili. And all I wanted to do was cry by the way. This chapter was soo emotional! But I have more to read now.
| LiL PriNCeSs Me chapter 47 . 3/3/2013
I'm sooooo sorry again! there's been so much going on this week. I had no idea you were heading in this direction. I must read on.