Honestly one of the best fanfictions ive read in a long time. I cried like a baby. Thank you for an amazing piece, such a talented writer.

WOW! Just... WOW!

I started. this fic yyyeeaarrss ago, but I didn't read past chapter 10. I guess it wasn't ready to read something so amazing! So I started from the beginning, of course! The slowest burn to ever walk this earth. By so worth it!

Thank you!

I cannot adequately explain the absolute master piece this is, I have never never cried so deeply and with my soul as I did readying this, forever saving this

An excellent story, but bloody hell, REALLY difficult to finish! My emotions are all over the place. My eyes sting, my nose is really sore because I have been crying solid for the last 2 hours!
This story hurts. Right in the heart.
But, I still want to say thank you for writing and sharing. A story that can cause such reactions and emotions needs to be acknowledged. Well done for making me feel so much. For turning me into a sobbing mess. Now I must go and bathe my eyes because they are really sore!

this story was amazing

You are a very cruel writer! Very cruel ... -_-
You made me cry! T_T
You wrote this story well. I like it :D

HOOOOOOLY SHIT! Excuse me while I sob uncontrollably into my pillow at 1AM. Your writing is incredible. I laughed, I cried, I felt every damn emotion and now i have to sit here with my heart broken in the best way. Thank you for sharing your work. 3

O wow this is one of the best docs I’ve ever read. It’s so good I stayed awake until 2 am just to finish reading this even though I have a Gail to sleep more this year but honestly I much prefer reading this fic. Love it!(although,not gonna lie,all the crying you made me do wasn’t funny)

Just forgot to tell youTHANK YOU FOR THE HAPPY ENDING

So I finally finished this story !
Thank you for your hard work. You made me laugh and cry, it is usally the sign of a good story.
I enjoyed it but I don't think I will read it again because if all the angst xD and because I'm so angry that Fili juste gave up so easily, did nit wven try to live. But that makes sense in the end.
So thank you again

In all this angst, I still find funny that Bilbo refers to Thorin as "his friend" despite his admitted and wrll known love for him.
But now I just want to cry for hours because they are all dead and Bilbo is alone, again. Because we know that even if he will care for Frodon hreatly, he will never be able to love again. Because all hr had was few days oh happiness and then death and suffering.
I would have liked that Fili fought for his uncle instead of waiting for death, even if I understand why you wrote it that way, I still think that is a whole new level of selfish.

Nooooo so much angst ToT Thorin, you fool ! That is a level of idiocy I could never even imagine ! I hope this story ends well, I'm in despair right now TnT

Now you're timing is funny. When I read the description about Bilbo's wooden figure, I thought "he's looking at Thorin with love but he's not able to recognize it, and the sadness come from the aknowledgment that his love is suffering". Then I read your note and I agree that friendship takes time, and love enven more, especially for someone like Bilbo or Thorin. However I think most of the compagny already realized what is growing between those two

It may be a slow slow burn but it really makes sense that they don't fall in love in 3 day with no challenge. Considering their characters, which you are remarquably well describing, I was even almost surprised that Thorin dis not throw Bilbo away after a week.. .
Thank you for the whole explanation though, it is nice to see that I follow your thinking. Now I return to my reading and I'll let you another review later

ok I cried a lot while I readed this chapter really a lot !
I was afraid because I hate bad end but I really wanted to finish this story I didn't know why but eventually the end was great !
thanks to have writes an amazing story !
you make me feel all emotions !
congratulations !
.
(sorry for my poor English it's not my mother tongue )