Reviews for Harry Potter and The Promise Ring |
---|
![]() ![]() EW THAT'S GROSS SNAPE AND LILY WHY WOULD YOU WANT A GREASY HEAD GIT LIKE THAT WITH LILY |
![]() ![]() Sorry i haven't written in a while but i was just so into these chapters that i forgot to but i will now so i thought all the previous chapters were great and i can't wait to read everything else. rjrshgyjy irgeuirytriytri tyiosyurejtotgodjirt retur8tyioutry ;lkgqwugfhr4356384p23432553 fjfoithlgkhptoru86589843930-4568649875584753847 trhktrsfhoito[ui9r60uitopyuirtokhojtrp tr;lhk;lk;hlktglyt hrotyptr,ypkthttr |
![]() ![]() This is really good, and your 'narcissistic conman' coment made me laugh *really* hard - it reminded me of Cptn. Jack Harkness from the 'Doctor Who' and 'Torchwood' tv series; Jack is hot and he knows it, but his and Lockheart's personalities are total oppoites! |
![]() ![]() The whole idea of sending the letters to the wrong person was absolutely brilliant! |
![]() ![]() ![]() yeah, I enjoyed this one really much, aspecially since you had really really cool guessings! For not even reading the 5 book, you got some things straight right (like that thing with Snape loving Lily and going back to the good side 'cause of her dad) That was really great :) Thanks for writing it, even if it was really a long time ago and I don't if you will even get this review, but I'm writing it anyway :) Lee |
![]() ![]() ![]() did you seriously make lily from slytherin? given what was known about lily and james even in the 4th book, james would NOT have looked at ANY slytherin with love |
![]() ![]() ![]() why are you abbreviating abbreviations? O.? N.E.? |
![]() ![]() ![]() nice theory on why dumbledore is the only one voldemort ever feared! if i didnt already know why, id would totally think that was the main reason! although i do think it might have played some role...i never even reall considered that before. good job! |
![]() ![]() ![]() Any chance for a sequel to this story... |
![]() ![]() ![]() this was an amazing story, |
![]() ![]() ![]() I enjoyed this story. I don't know what to write in the review, anyway very good! |
![]() ![]() ![]() This was brilliant! The bit about the promise ring being Snape's was a really unexpected twist and Sally was so sweet! This was a great fic and it was really original, so thanks for writing this! |
![]() ![]() ![]() good fic. I am of the opinion that you should have ended it with a time skip and Harry and Ginny making their own rings...maybe even with a bit of "help" from snape..something along the lines of. "Potter, If you can stop admiring yourself long enough you may find it helpful to look up potions. Doubtless you need all the practice you can get" |
![]() ![]() ![]() I'm reviewing here as i've already reviewed the last chapter the first time i read this... and this confirm my suspect that i had read this beforehand, at some scenes i had a feeling of deja vue but some other didn't tell me anything. Now i suppose i remembered the better or emotionally stron ger ones. So, have i wasted my time rereading a story when there are thousands and thousands of unread story around ? No, i didn't wasted my time as i enjoyed the time spent whit this story. Thank you, ciao! |
![]() ![]() ![]() Very good. I specially liked all that misleading with Cho, that was very well done. The rescue of the Weasleys and Snape was a bit overdone, but considering we're talking about Harry Potter, I guess it's just in tune with the books, even if it's AU. |