|Reviews for All Our Secrets|
| annimun16 chapter 20 . 3/20
it is just WOW. so much emotions involved, just wow. let out a big sigh with still-not-believe-that-this-amazing-story-exist-and-finally-end smile thank you
| MonJoh chapter 18 . 12/9/2016
That was an insightful take on The Sorcerer's Apprentice. Also, nice balance throughout of Merlin taking responsibility for the ways he let Morgana down without blaming him for all her poor judgement/choices. Aithusa's "all our secrets" is heartbreaking in this context.
| MonJoh chapter 20 . 12/8/2016
Fantastic. Well done. Real emotion but you kept to canon. Could barely "put it down". Everything Jeremy Webb kept us from seeing. Well ... and the M rated stuff BBC couldn't show. Nice job.
| pat chapter 15 . 5/13/2016
Why is it this scene is kinky here yet disturbing in fifty shades of grey?
| MistyNocturne chapter 20 . 12/21/2015
Canon with benefits. The moment I saw that, I knew. I KNEW I was settling for a masochistic read. But honestly? I'm glad you did it that way. Because if you'd diverged, there would be less punch. It makes the entire original series more meaningful now, in a way. With tears running down my cheeks and my nose annoyingly blocked now, I salute you.
Thanks for the great interpretation.
| Bismark195 chapter 20 . 12/6/2014
AWWWW! Right in the feels. I love it so much. I read it through, then went back and watched the show from the beginning, pausing to read this story at the designated times. It made it so much better overall. Well done.
| moosejuice5 chapter 20 . 5/16/2014
Very nice, sad ending
| InsanityRunsInMyBlood chapter 20 . 4/15/2014
Tears down my fucking cheeks, I tell you.
How dare you do this.
Utter and inconsolable pain.
(which is my way of saying this is bloody brilliant, by the way...one of the very best merganas i've seen on this bloody website)
| wryter501 chapter 19 . 4/1/2014
i liked this chapter, in a sad, strange way. after your last, with morgana healed and agreeing to try to be a good person, anyway, i did wonder... but you've done a good job with morgana's pov during this time of imprisonment/torture to make her the person that returns in season 5... believing, mistakenly, that merlin and arthur's betrayal had led to her capture by the sarrum...
| wryter501 chapter 16 . 4/1/2014
this made me a little sad, that merlin sent aithusa to morgana... saving her life and giving her the means to create the blade that kills arthur... :(
| wryter501 chapter 13 . 4/1/2014
omg was that line of merlin's on purpose - this is really what you want? (referencing her nightmare of her death at emrys' hands, maybe?)
| wryter501 chapter 11 . 4/1/2014
you know, morgana was not some innocent bystander that merlin had to poison for arthur's sake... she'd already plotted against uther's life twice to merlin's knowledge... and how many opportunities did he give her to come clean about her part in the sleeping spell plot? she lied to him half a dozen times that ep. alone... her choices led to that outcome, not his... thank you for getting their distinctive thoughts and motivations so clear - usually people will take one side or the other for truth, instead of leaving it depending on the point of view...
| wryter501 chapter 10 . 4/1/2014
i was a little worried that staying in canon meant more heartbreak for merlin (falling in love with morgana only to have to kill her - well, eventually)... but a merlin that can distance his love from his lust is a darker, more mature merlin, i think...
| wryter501 chapter 7 . 3/31/2014
that one scene merlin confronts morgana in arthur's chamber when she's stealing his keys is one of my favorites... arthur's on the training ground, every day, same time, same place... and he gives her this little smile...
| Elaine du Lac chapter 13 . 11/11/2013
Love Morgana's Merthur mention. And Merlin's incredulous reaction!