Reviews for Reunion in Minas Tirith
Aria Breuer chapter 9 . 5/12/2013
Well, I must say this was another well-written story and a quick read. I must admit, I'm not on Pippin's side much with this story, due to his behavior towards Frodo. Naturally, since this story is during the events near the end of 'The Return of the King', I'm defending Frodo, given how everyone's treating him, as if he did more than take the Ring to Mordor. I'm not sure if I'm one of the few or more that understands his situation, in some ways.

Overall, you pulled off another decent story, managing once again to keep everyone in-character. I hope you continue to keep writing, as well as keeping everyone in-character. I seem to turn the conversation towards the characters and less on the writer when that happens, due to the fact that they're involved in the story.

-Aria Breuer

P.S. Once again, I'm putting another story into my community. The reason I'm putting this story in the community is that you have a couple of valid points concerning Frodo, at least with the titles and how those at Minas Tirith treated him, including his friends. I hope this is all right with you.
JensonBensen chapter 9 . 8/7/2012
This was absolutely fantastic! I never stopped smiling the entire time I read it! I've actually been going through all of your stories (and favorite-ing quite a few... Though not reviewing, which made me feel like a dirtbag, but I was just too anxious to keep reading your next one... pathetic I know...) and this one is definitely one of my top faves! I just love Faramir and the Hobbits so to read such a wonderful story with humor and charm that combined the two! Much praise to you!
sassyfriend chapter 9 . 11/14/2011
:D very good
InuEnki chapter 4 . 8/29/2011
This whole chapter made me LOL at work until I started getting odd looks from co-workers. Hmm, maybe I should stop reading Shirebound's fanfic at work...~ponders~...Naaah! :)

"He's succumbed at last, Legolas," said Merry solemnly. "Too many banquets."

"Has he?" Legolas smiled and squatted down next to Pippin. "That seems an unlikely cause of death for any hobbit." He ran his finger lightly across Frodo's middle, eliciting a convulsive giggle from the dead hero.

"Still a bit of life left in him yet," said Gimli gruffly. "Perhaps tonight's dinner will be the one to do him in."

LOLLOLLOL Both adorable and hilarious! It's adorlarious!
Nikikeya chapter 9 . 8/14/2011
I laughed all the way through this, in fact, when Frodo pretended to "Die" I literally was laughing so hard I couldn't breath. I LOVE THIS STORY! XDDDDD
amyfan4ever chapter 8 . 6/15/2011
Honestly, I think you just become my new favorite author. :]

I love everything about your stories, very cute, funny, you include all the characters, clean and very hobbity. A perfect mix.

Love this one, I like the idea of them having a fued, but it might not be a fued and just the many layers of it. Very funny.

The only thing I was sad about with this story is we didn't get to see what Pip was planning :c I wanted to know what he was cooking up in that head of his XD Not to mention what Sam and Merry would of done, poor guys. Dragged into the middle of it.

Least they didn't try to pull Aragorn into the middle of it, wonder if he would of stayed out, taken a side or just put an end to it...

Anyway, kudos on a great story :]
CaelumBlue chapter 9 . 9/20/2010
I laughed. Hard. Every chapter. It's so sweet, and innocent, and...and sweet! And hilarious.

*holds the story tight and snuggles it*
Haurvatat chapter 9 . 7/31/2010
I know quite well you must be getting tired of seeing my username in your inbox (spam attack ftw), but I'll burden you with one more.

Just needed to let you know that you are *magical* beyond all comprehension. I could hardly breathe for laughing during ALL the "Reunion in _" pieces. F*cking MAGICAL.

Tony WildRiver chapter 9 . 5/25/2010
Holy Cow, this story had me giggling more times than I can think of. I especially loved the random bits with other characters. Loved Legolas and Gimli at the end of the 8th chapter. Fantastic job! _
Desertfyre chapter 9 . 4/23/2010
rofl! I really enjoyed this story! Great job!
koryssa-kory chapter 9 . 2/14/2010
hahaha! the tenacity of hobbits! what more can i say? O
Gyreflight chapter 9 . 12/29/2009
My apologies - I really should have written you some kind of appreciation long before now. Your hobbit fics were some of the first I read and really connected to, and I wanted to thank you for that. Reunion at Minas Tirith was the first one I picked up, as this fic-idea was something I had hoped to discover for some time - I really like book!Faramir, and had always wanted to see him, Frodo and Sam together in peacetime, fulfilling that unlikely wish for "someday..."

Done well, as this is, there is a great appeal to seeing familiar faces, deeds and places through other's eyes, and hobbits benefit from this more than most as their whole approach is so down-to-earth, do-what-comes-next, that it seems to be easy to overlook them until they're seen in context. It’s a pity there aren't more Frodo and Faramir fics (or Eowyn and Merry for that matter), as they make good foils for each other.

It doesn't hurt that this is genuinely amusing too (hobbits doing what comes naturally again).

Anyway, I hope that it pleases you to know that I have several of your fics saved to my computer so that I can come back to them whenever I feel hobbity :-) Actually, I think yours probably account for about half of all the hobbit fics on my computer…

Thanks for the read.

bethahnee chapter 9 . 4/13/2005
I'm DYING to know what the Elvish said! what could possibly have made Pippin so revengeful?

Anargil _~
Captain Pagie chapter 9 . 10/31/2004
This story is so awsome!

-LiL Pippin Padfoot
Vilya0 chapter 9 . 8/16/2004
Hello! It's me! I'm so sorry it took me this long to review again but I have been very busy lately. Plus, I wanted to make a fan fiction break because I read so much at a time that I mixed up some stories and all. I really like your happy fics, it's so pleasant to read. Seeing people like the hobbits who suffered so much during their journey having again a simple life and being more happy than sad is so great.

By the way, my translation of "Can you sing, Master Hobbit" has been really appreciated by the readers. Thanks again for letting me translate it. Mara mesta.
213 | « Prev Page 1 .. 2 3 4 5 6 13 .. Last Next »