|Reviews for Without Thorn the Rose|
| Established Insanity chapter 16 . 3/1
Amazing... I've never read anything like this before, and can't wait for you to post the sequel!
| Niji-neko chapter 16 . 2/16
Omg!...such a cliffhanger! Absolutely love the whole fic, the relashionship between Harry and his father, the need to be loved. Love his reactions and even tough he is missing part of his soul, he's still a child. Hnnn so the goddess possessed the body of his grand mother? or that was the guise she used before and she is really his grandmother ? It would explaing his part dementor nature. hnnn hnnn
Have a good one :)
| iheartfictionalbadguys chapter 7 . 2/10
Whew, tense but absolutely fantastic chapter. I was ready for Lovegood to start chanting about chutulu and dagon heh. Can't wait to find out more about the thing that ate the patronus!
| iheartfictionalbadguys chapter 2 . 2/10
not actually being related to Petunia, priceless. I'm glad Remus had the foresight to give the poor kid a portkey, James is kinda scary.
| iheartfictionalbadguys chapter 1 . 2/10
Really amazing start, I don't understand why this doesn't have more reviews. Loved the snake.
| KatzeIason69 chapter 16 . 2/6
wow :)* can't wait till you do the sequels to this story.
| vsama chapter 6 . 2/2
Any man who can fight a bear with his bare hands is aces in my book.
| Nobody'sNobody chapter 16 . 12/3/2013
Well, wow. This story was amazing. I loved it! Harry seems pretty powerful, but he really has nothing else in his life going for him except for his magic to focus on. I love how you handled the strain in the relationships of the characters in this story. The one between harry and james in particular, is so heart breaking because you didnt go over the top. Alot of the strain is what isnt being said or done. In a lot of other fics ive seen, authors just go all out and full on abuse harry. The more ... realistic? approach you chose stings all the more because its relatable on some level. Idk if im explaining myself correctly, but i hope you get the point.
The setup that you went through in this section leaves me excited for more, and im glad you hinted that this dementor goddess will be coming back. If it were possible to favorite multiple times, i would.
| Nobody'sNobody chapter 1 . 12/2/2013
My goodness. Where has this story been? Im loving this first chapter!
| August Pyro chapter 9 . 12/2/2013
Sooooo for Christmas I definitely wish for a dementor's robe :D
| August Pyro chapter 8 . 11/29/2013
The focus on Dementors was something I totally did not expect when I read the story for the first time. It was something (among others) that really made me actually recommend your story to everyone :) Oh and by the way I really like that there are lot of female characters in your story. Often when writers decide to write slash they literally forget about females existence (and it's really annoying). So, thank you! D
| August Pyro chapter 7 . 11/28/2013
I'm not totally Luna's fan and sometimes she really annoy me, but I'm willing to get to like her if you continue to write her the way you do. I'm glad she actually do something more than tossing some odd commentaries. I hope to see more of her, as a Harry's friend and (first?) ally.
Oh and the black mist creature? You have all my attention now :D
| August Pyro chapter 6 . 11/28/2013
I like the mythological staff. It makes the story original and is interesting as a whole :)
Remus is a nice character. A kind one, I mean. I want to say that I like him very much. I'm happy to know Harry cares for him too. My teacher once told me, that emotional people are easy to manipulate. Well, it's totally true, as I see here. :D
| August Pyro chapter 5 . 11/28/2013
Harry getting this coral as something to focus his magic with is one of the most original twists on wand I've ever read. He will be so powerful now - he will always be able to cast magic and without some shitty explanations - this one is reasonable and I love it.
Harry wanted to sleep in a cold cellar? Hey, Harry I think you will totally love the broom closets in the future (if you know what I mean :D) Joke.
| August Pyro chapter 4 . 11/28/2013
Harry being a pureblood and not a Potter? I'm curious what you are gonna do with this twist!
I like Bjorn. I really do. He's simple and yet wisdom in fields that British wizards never dreamed of.