Reviews for Bilbo son of Durin
Lina03 chapter 37 . 11/12/2016
Yay, thanks for sharing this wonderful story; it was a lovely read! )
Guest chapter 5 . 8/7/2016
If a kid's been adopted by someone of a different culture and a "family friend" just so happen to see him. I don't see why it would be ok to take him away, insist on snatching him from his home to try to assimilate him with "his own kind". The adopted family would either give their kid consent to go explore if he was ready to seek his background, but I can't see them allowing basically a stranger (no matter how powerful) to take him away when he's not ready. Especially with a character like Gandolf who'd push but not so directly unless he had an urgency to do so. For having raised the hobbit as their own since he was '2', the family bond seems lacking. For him to be a teen (a baby in dwarves eyes) I can't see any parents letting him experience potentual culturual backlash when the kid is reluctant to do so.
jumpinthecart chapter 28 . 5/22/2016
I thought that the orcs and goblins counted as one and the eagles were the fifth army.
Mysteryfan17 chapter 36 . 4/10/2016
You had me SOBBING for Filli and Ori and I aalmost couln't bring myself to continue. I still have tears in my eyes but they have shifted to happy even if they haven't stopped. My heart was so... in pieces but I loved the idea of the Arkenstone being pure magic. So happy and am defiantly going over to read that sequel. 10/10
Acacia Cottonwood chapter 8 . 12/29/2015
Love this story. This is my first Hobbit FF. I've read crossovers but not pure Hobbit. It's pretty amazing. Thank you.
supremedonutruler chapter 1 . 8/9/2015
i've read one chapter and i'm absolutely in love with this idea already! thank you for writing this
Liliana Dragonshard chapter 37 . 8/3/2015
Welp, I'm happy and will be looking for that story then. :-) I really love how you've played up this angle, it is a very fantastically and extremely well-crafted fanfic. I absolutely love it. :-D Keep it up and Happy Story Weaving!

Liliana Dragonshard
Liliana Dragonshard chapter 28 . 8/3/2015
Woah. I feel bad for Bilbo right now. Bad enough to be a dwarf and rejected by loved ones, but to be adopted and then turned on? Let's hope it all works out in the end. Keep it up and Happy Story Weaving!

Liliana Dragonshard
Liliana Dragonshard chapter 1 . 8/1/2015
Eeee!(I pitched squealing) I love it! I think that this is adorable! Makes me wonder, though, how Bilbo is going to react to being told he was adopted, or at least growing up swifter than his dwarfish family members. Keep it up and Happy Story Weaving!

Liliana Dragonshard
ThomE.Gemcity-06 chapter 36 . 6/9/2015
I really like this story concept. Thorin raising Bilbo as his son, instead of them being strangers until the quest to take back Erebor. I liked seeing how Bilbo's gentle soul mixed with the tough brashness of being raised a Dwarf. It was nice to see Thorin vulnerable like that, and Bilbo with two big brothers like Fili and Kili. I was dubious when I found out that you were tying in the movies/book, because it would be such a long repeat, but you added your own. This was really great and I can't wait to read this sequel your on about! :) :)
ThomE.Gemcity-06 chapter 34 . 6/9/2015
Yes! Fili's back and Ori too. What an interesting way to turn the Arkenstone to good use. :)
ThomE.Gemcity-06 chapter 32 . 6/9/2015
So horrible that Kili has to wake up to find out that his big brother died and he wasn't able to be there for him.
I holding you to that happiness. After Fili, I need some bad and so do the Dwarfs.
ThomE.Gemcity-06 chapter 31 . 6/9/2015
I'm really upset here that you killed Fili. I thought that since you changed so many things, you might've let him live.
ThomE.Gemcity-06 chapter 23 . 6/9/2015
An interesting encounter with Legolas and Bilbo. Happy about the kindness he showed Bilbo instead of turning him in to his father.
ThomE.Gemcity-06 chapter 16 . 6/9/2015
This chapter was really well written. I like the dramatic twist where you had Bilbo hanging over the edge in Fili's grasp and had him sacrifice himself for his brother.
352 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »