|Reviews for Adventures outside Middle Earth|
| sian22 chapter 23 . 2/28
"weave your own lentils" omg...too funny
you aren't showing yet...helpless out loud laughter
But to your Wyre Piddle I give you "Conception Bay" which is seriously down the coast from "Hearts Desire" and 'Cupids'. no seriously. All of them of course are in Newfoundland.
| sian22 chapter 22 . 2/10
Oh no...not Gimli too... well if he winds up in Wales maybe it won't be so noticeable
| sian22 chapter 21 . 2/10
Oh lord..helpless laughter. Celeborn's line was just brilliant.
Legolas is so wonderful I fear he is verging on Gary Stu. Ginger cookies and clearblue. what a catch
| sian22 chapter 20 . 1/30
Gladdy to send us to Reno *double snort*
Smart Mary Sue...thank heaven they are out there
| sian22 chapter 17 . 1/30
Every cloud has a silver lining :D I love your wiseass Haldir
Very exciting ending...
| sian22 chapter 16 . 1/30
Your writing is just fabulous here...yes this is comedy but it is tight, funny, interesting, surprising comedy.
| sian22 chapter 15 . 1/30
Woohoo..Haldir and Sue...nice to see him in a non-slash something for a change...and see Celeborn get to barb at Gladdy...
| sian22 chapter 14 . 1/30
So much more than just a river...great line
I like Southwell...tenacious bugger indeed
| sian22 chapter 13 . 1/23
"I am sorry Dave" some of the most chilling words in cinema...
Love the asides about Faramir enjoying watching the advisors freaking about Aragorn's ranger tendencies..and the bit about Arwen galloping off.
| sian22 chapter 11 . 1/12
This was serious but thoughtful, introspective and very plausibly interwove the differences between modern and ME warfare. I particularly liked Legolas' reaction to the symphony... his confusion over her reaction and Helena coming to see the connection with her own visceral reaction. I wondered though if Legolas would see an echo of the One Ring in that weapon, given Tolkien's perspective that 'machines' of war were so greatly evil..an atomic bomb being the ultimate machine of destruction...orcs being essentially witless pieces of the whole driven by their hideous general
| sian22 chapter 12 . 1/12
"A note of slight regret..." :D All I could think of was "what about her plastic 'parts'..."
"Strange conversations about poultry" ..oh ya that happens to me all the time...
You know..the fact that leggy doesn't lodge anything anywhere seems to be most 10th fangirls great regret :)
| sian22 chapter 10 . 1/5
Your authorial asides are almost as good as the story! :)
Hilarious..Galadriel getting flamed...brilliant...
yay..Damrod and Anborn!
| sian22 chapter 9 . 1/5
Legolas's observations about human pastimes had me laughing out loud.
Thank god he didn't fall into Canada...our linguistic derivativeness wrt proper westron, coupled with sledding and toques and beer would have really worried him :)
| sian22 chapter 8 . 1/5
Brilliant..absolutely briliant...DC Marvel-Dr Who-with a touch of Swiftly Tilting planet somehow.
Love Jonathon and Matt novel approach to linear equations...
| sian22 chapter 7 . 1/5
Legolas as a concubine behind the veil...rofl
Noo..not guns in middle earth...someone will have done Gunsmoke in Rohan as a result..eep..