|Reviews for With Careful Magic Caught Inside|
| Gill4623 chapter 7 . 11/18
Loved the story - thank you
| drasticactions chapter 7 . 8/17
very sweet ending, for some reason I love that he was stuck in a Tiffany lamp instead of an oil lamp. I'm not sure why some people are confused, I think it was unselfish of her because she really wanted to say she wanted him to love her but; she wished he would instead go out and find love. She knew she was risking getting caught in the lamp by making that wish as it might have been too much, but the wish was for him for him to be free instead of using that wish on her self, which I think kept her from being trapped. He came back because he realized she must already love him or potentially love him as she basically used all her wishes to try to free him, and he didn't need to look for love because it was already there. I think it was the perfect lenght.
| AwkwardIdeasLeadToThis chapter 7 . 7/22
I was 2 seconds from stabbing snape.
| xxxLeanniexxx chapter 7 . 5/6
This is the best line out of the whole thing "or that teenage boys up and down the country were learning hair straightening charms from their sisters in order to mimic the trademark sweep of hair that brushed his shoulders and hid his eyes." Love it
| jensteed chapter 7 . 12/31/2014
Great story, so different to anything I've read before.
| jensteed chapter 3 . 12/31/2014
Genie Snape...well that's a new one, haha. This'll be interesting to see where it goes :D
| Bumbles chapter 7 . 10/3/2014
Re-reading this story for the fourth time and really, it's the BEST romance-related Snape fic out there. Excellent writing and the sweetest happy-ending ever. The perfect medicine for a cloudy day-in with a head cold.
| Guest chapter 7 . 7/9/2014
its a sad story - even with this happy ending
the thought of severus beeing binded by another master and this time without hope...
i love all yout stories this far but this one holds a speziell place
| Dimac99 chapter 7 . 1/27/2014
I'm not sure I understand how her wishing for his love didn't make her selfish enough to be caught in the same trap as he was, but I really enjoyed the story all the same and one must never look a Happily Ever After ending in the mouth!
| kittyperry chapter 7 . 11/12/2013
I really enjoyed the concept. Intriguing.
| littlemisselvee chapter 7 . 11/3/2013
I agree with many others: good premise. I realize you're trying to keep it short, but Snape's motivation at the end of the plot seemed to be too vague for me. It didn't make much sense from his perspective. You do have a lovely writing style; very clean and clear. Thank you for sharing. I really did enjoy it aside from the niggle at the end.
| Garnet chapter 7 . 9/16/2013
Really enjoyed reading this story. I would greatly appreciate it if you would continue with another of your stories; 'The Tyger and the Lamb'. It's a very sweet story and I'm looking forward to reading more chapters. Please? Pretty please?
| Yu Silabar chapter 7 . 7/17/2013
Fantastic story, really a great one! Thanks for sharing.
| I M Sterling chapter 7 . 6/16/2013
| mom2divas chapter 7 . 6/7/2013
Very intriguing story. I've never seen one like it and loved your take on the genie. Glad they got their happy ending.