|Reviews for One Year to Rule Them All|
| Flovios chapter 38 . 1/28
| ThatBookGirl96 chapter 22 . 11/18/2014
Hey! So, I've been following your stories for a while now , and I just wanted to say that I think you're doing a great job. Life's been crazy lately, so I haven't had much time to read, but I try to as much as I can. You write amazing stories, so no matter how long I go without reading, I will always come back to them. I'm invested in these characters, and I can't wait to see how things pan out.
I know you said you got some negative reactions to this chapter regarding Soulless Sam and his actions, but I just want to let you know that I thought this was a great chapter. The subject matter was touchy, but you handled it with grace. Plus, this is SOULLESS Sam we're talking about here. This is exactly the kind of thing he would have done. So I applaud you for being brave enough to explore this darker side of the Supernatural story. Keep doing what you do best, and know that people truly appreciate your hard work.
| ThatBookGirl96 chapter 10 . 10/19/2014
I lost it at "I really like you too, Sam". Beautiful writing in this chapter!
| Guest chapter 48 . 8/1/2014
How could you do that i mean after everything that they have been through they deserved it. Honetly i want Sam to get his soul back but i didnt want Dean and Lizzy normal lives to be ruined
| Trucklady53 chapter 7 . 7/15/2014
I have been reading all of these from the beginning and am just intrigued and cannot stop reading. I had planned on waiting until I caught up to the current story but I had to speak up with the flaw in canon here. The cemetery that the big fight was to take place and that Sam did the nose dive into the cage was outside of Lawrence, Kansas. That is the field that Sam woke up in. They did originally meet Lucifer in Detroit but that is not where they ended up in. Back to my reading. I have to say some of these are keeping me up till 12:30-1:00 in the morning because I cannot stop reading them.
| ToriMe chapter 49 . 6/20/2014
You called their life quaint. Oh shit.
I cried my eyes out in this chapter! Sooooo good.
Your Samuel was way better than canon. I bought it all. Great job!
But your Sam interactions...I got it. I soooo got it. Even Soulless he understood. Sam is brilliant and although he's not unhappy about not having a soul he is quite alert to all wants them back in hunting for what he doesn't have. Especially Lizzy. She always had more empathy period. While Sam doesn't have it and can't really use it himself , he wants it in his arsenal. Wow. Cold. And soooo accurate.
And where the hell is my Castiel? ;) yummm
Love ya Girl! Soooooo great!
| ToriMe chapter 48 . 6/20/2014
I don't hate you! What a great job you've done! Actually it all makes soooo much more sense in Newbie-world! Sam staying away to the point they were on the verge of committed purposeful pregnancy? Shiiiiit.
And Sam. What a fabulous, heartbreaking job you've done there! Sam without his soul is a shattering thing...and you've shown that. Crap...I'm tearing up again...
Never really liked the canon episode where Dean is djinned and Sam comes back. Probably because I fucking hate Brain Donor Lisa (oops, was that out loud?! Lol :))
Coming back to the life was a relief in canon. The relief should have been being with Sam again (albeit in his Soulless state) but instead in canon it got screwed up four ways to Sunday. It's bad when a chick can screw things up like that. And hey... I don't know... Maybe the writers porked the puppy. Jensen is a fabulous actor... Maybe he just didn't click with the actress. Maybe the point was Lisa sucked ass(I can get with that one...).
But no matter what, if you go with Stated Intent
And not subtext, Newbieworld has it over canon. Hands down. :)
And Cas. Haven't seen him for a while...
(Want to get his read on his namesake! :). )
But wow. Pissed protective angel! Sooo sexy! You could just write me in there... Yum!
Love this and you! My Castiel (the cat) is in his favorite perch,reading over my shoulder!
| ToriMe chapter 46 . 6/20/2014
I Loved Loved Loved this! Dean and Lizzy at the bar! First off... I wanna go! Would so drink with them! :) But how great was that interlude you constructed? Ryan and Donovan...FRICK and FRACK. Donovan was cool though! And Ryan? Poor boy. But then no one has a chance against the "Old Man"... :) Soo yummy.
| ToriMe chapter 45 . 6/20/2014
No no no!
Dean is soooooo right! Andy is a fucking asshole...
Oh, he didn't say that? Just dick? Well, he was confused... And, you know...SOFT. Been out of the life for a while. Lois on the other hand rocked my socks...just sayin...
Excellent chapter! :)
| ToriMe chapter 44 . 6/20/2014
Okay,sweetheart... I sobbed like a baby. Sam in hell frequently does that to me. But really. The evil that is your Lucifer...at this point Sam wants/needs to go to crazy town. It is his breaking point. And Lucifer just propped him up? Gave him Mom? To get a little more mileage? You are soooo damn good at this! You know in real life if anyone made me cry like this I would not be congratulating them. Things would be different. Promise.
But this isn't real life is it? ;)
Oh Dean! What a sweetheart! And I did the Three Stooges thing too. I think all of us of "a certain age" ...kids now have to you tube them? Wrong. And am I wrong but Shemp was a fill-in stooge? Larry, Moe and Curly...with Shemp later. Memories...
| ToriMe chapter 43 . 6/20/2014
Girl... Kaylee is awesome! Like her SOOO much! Glad she's headed on that hunter path and hope we get to see her again! (Who am I kidding...Newbie always has a plan! :). )
Sam and Kaylee were hot. Nice. ;)
Some help, if you want it... Beginning of chapter... It's Rabbi with 2 b's... Also, I've been a lot of things and typically words like Mass and parish belong with Priest not Pastor. Say stuff like Services and Congregation. Anything too Catholic sounding doesn't work in a Protestant-verse and viceaversa.
Grew up in the Philly area, live in the South now, had a Jewish best friend as a kid and am old enough for a few existential crisis of my own. You pick up stuff...
But nitty gritty...fabulous as usual!
| ToriMe chapter 42 . 6/19/2014
Loves the Notebook?!
Love this and you...
| ToriMe chapter 41 . 6/19/2014
Oh Wow. Lou's Anniversary. :(
Best one yet for Lizzy. But Soulless? Thought Bobby was gonna rip him a new one! I freakin love Bobby! Family! Hunter! Alcoholic! Total package! Ha!:) But I really do...
You really took the opportunity to show Soulless for what he is. Kudos! Nothing shows it like a Lou -versary! Which is why I'm gonna end this review. Enough melancholy headspace! Onwards!
| ToriMe chapter 39 . 6/19/2014
What a ...I don't even know what to call it. Chapter is too cut and dried... And it was longer anyway. Moment? Interlude? Fugue state? The tangible remains of what the fuck?!
Seriously...how do you do it? Hotter than hell. Even for me and...stuff.
Actually you've helped a lot. I thank you. My shrink thanks you...;)
Oh girl! I hope I get to meet you someday! What a time we will have!
Jameson is waiting...
| ToriMe chapter 34 . 6/19/2014
Loved this chapter!
Do you have tattoos? I'm just about to take the plunge so I loved all the discussion! Love that the characters agree with me... Tats are great but should have meaning.
And I've got to say it...
After all, Lizzy really does wear her heart out there on her sleeve.
Alright... Just hit me now! I deserve it! But I HAD to! But Lizzy Noonan Winchester is totally badass! So want to buy her a drink or four and watch a Pats game! No one understands football or hometown loyalty like her and Lou!
Anyway...love the tats! And Sam's commemorative brought the waterworks as you figured, cheeky bitch!