|Reviews for My Gilded Life: An Alternate Ending|
| Guest chapter 1 . 1/28
sorry to say but if dumbledore was that powerful he would've wasted voldemort himself instead of relying on children to do his work for him.
| Abyssal Angel chapter 1 . 11/6/2013
Interesting. I can't say I really agree or disagree with your assessment of the story, considering from a character's standpoint, Lockhart was simply going with the flow trying to do what he could to correct the wrongs done in the HarryPotter-Verse. His methods left a lot to be desired, certainly. But whether we consider it manipulation or not, those Lockhart introduced those mind altering techniques on at least asked for it first. Granted, I personally wouldn't have gone for that myself. It's one thing to alter self. It's completely another to alter another, even at their own behest.
In the end though, the main thing I disagree with is your twisting of Dumbledore from Skysaber's original purpose. While manipulative Dumbles is canon, manipulative evil Dumbles is an alternate take on the Harry Potter-verse that was invented by fanfiction and used by fanfiction. As such, taking an Evil Dumbles and suddenly twisting him to be good manipulative Dumbles like in Canon, when Skysaber's story clearly isn't, is a perversion on his story that completely destroys the point of 'My Gilded Life', that is what happens to an ordinary person when they're thrown into an extraordinarily FUBARed situation, and how they go about trying to unscrew it up and the methods of doing such, particularly within the HP-Verse. That's my take on it anyway.
Ahem, I believe I've stepped on my soapbox though. I will step off and try to get to the point of this review. I both agree and disagree with you. 'My Gilded Life' was FUBAR from the get go. I don't want to know what kind of screwed up messiness my mind would become if I were to suddenly 'blend' with Gilderoy Lockhart. It's interesting to see some of the ideas posited about how one might go changing things in the HP-Verse though, and that, I believe is the whole point of the story.
| Preier chapter 1 . 10/11/2013
well that was... boring?
about on par with some of the bad part of PL's writing, in fact. when the shiny ideas and intriguing concepts are left behind for power grinding and self-justification
no, i'm not wholly enamored with his stories. but at least his characters have to "show their work" (often to the excess, even). saying : "you were a victim of mental rape" is a bit short.
what's sad is that there are lots of awful problems who could have been interestingly developped and denounced. most basic of all, the murder of dudley. not likely that harry, even with full memories, would have liked that. but, no, you had to drop a "boring invincible hero" down on your "mustache twirling villain".
oh, and you forgot religious proselytism in the "crimes commited" list.
anyway... i did not find this on par with your other tales. keep writing your own stories, they're much more interesting (and thank you for sharing them)
| Xynth chapter 1 . 9/12/2013
Perfect Lionheart is a hack. Plain and simple. He's a character bashing Gary Stu writer. What's worse is the sense of baseless superiority apparent in his writing. Sadly, his fans are an even bigger problem, promulgating the same terrible ideas and cliches found within. Plainy said, all of them are idiots and I hope that they never breed. This was highly amusing to read and few authors deserve it more.
| Sailor of dreams chapter 1 . 8/10/2013
By the way you complain about copywright infringement, but aren't you doing the same by writing this story without Perfect lionheart's permission?
| Sailor of dreams chapter 1 . 8/9/2013
After reading the various reviews, I'm afraid i can only agree with the minority authors not flaming Perfect Lionheart.
I have to agree with irfane on everything except the dursleys . In the first movie Harry's uncle, before the get in the car for their infamous trip to the zoo, tells him ''Any funny business, any at all, and you'll be going without meals for a week...kly.'' Direct qoute form the first movie.
I respect Brother Bludgeon's opinion, but cannot agree with it. PL doesn't give demonized traits to his characters, rather, he is a firm believer of you reap what you sow. You know the old saying, an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth? That's what he's using to punish the criminals of his story's, the philosophical lesson of ''If you don't want to suffer the punishment, DON'T COMMIT THE CRIME.'' There's nothing half baked about this, it couldn't be more clear.
The Sinful, you have to keep in mind Naruto and Sakura were KIDS, children are often singleminded about what they want. And stubbornly keep going after it, even against common sense and Naruto being what he was, a CHILD, his interest was a lot more innocent then you make it out to be. Especially as this was BEFORE they were exposed to the harsh realities of the ninja world. And by your argument, shouldn't Sakura be locked up in an asylum as well for going after Sasuke with equal, if not more, fervor? As for your other argument, it wasn't Naruto's decision to bring Sakura into the resets. His wives convinced HIM to include her, not the other way around. Finally, she wasn't redeemed because she was trying to kill herself, she was redeemed because she was being UNSELFISH.
If you don't like his stories, DON'T READ THEM. The only thing you're doing is ruining the fun for everyone that DOES like what he writes by trying to chase him off. Last time i checked the reviews for partially kissed and chunin exam day went over thirteen Thousand, THIRTEEN THOUSAND! We can decide for ourselves what we do or don't like.
| The Loose Canon chapter 1 . 7/24/2013
You should have ended the crime list with the copyright infringement for the more biting humor effect. I'm sorely disappointed in just how far he's slipped from his writings many years ago. I mean, he Stu-ed back then, too, but at least it was entertaining.
| Guest chapter 1 . 7/21/2013
That's pretty grimdark. Especially with the omniscient narrator who reminds me of Dumbledore.
| SONGUE chapter 1 . 7/19/2013
What have you done to me?! Why, why did you tell us of this story?
I was a happy reader, a happy writer... hell, a happy human being! Even after Rainbow Factory, Cupcakes and My Immortal, I was still reasonably detached of anger over silly stories.
But, no! I HAD to disbelieve you, as in my innocent state I told myself "No way can a story be THAT bad, it must be BAD but in a silly bad manner". I decided to check on it, my resolve set and my soul experienced my many horrible experiments from before.
What a fool, I was. To have read such a thing, filled me with such a rage, I barely could read the last two chapters, and around the Tenth I was already swallowing back the bile that I felt in my throat! I truly don't know what is written in the last few paragraphs, as my mind constantly told me, "read the last bit or you won't have the mental fortitude to finish anything else ever again!"
But, alas, your story made the nightmare end, and the world is, once again, a good place to be!
Thanks, Andrew Joshua Talon. Thank you.
| Eclipse1234 chapter 1 . 7/17/2013
Don't like it. Nuff said.
| irfane chapter 1 . 7/16/2013
In fairly poor taste. This 'ending' doesn't match the established story's reality, which the protagonist went to some lengths -in the story- to research and verify before basing his actions on them. The difference, as you put it, is in the first several chapters. Nevermind that some of the story is written from Albus's point of view.
Particularly, the mental alterations started as recovery and enhancement of Harry's own early memories and a small, precise splice of memories (working off of recently proven techniques)- with permission after full disclosure. The remainder was explicitly at the instigation of the Grangers and Potter themselves. (and justifiable as he was actively working to prevent: one death (granger daughter), two complete rewrites (the parents via Hermione), and one daughter's estrangement (Hermione after she undid the spell). -and he kept full backup copies of the original memories for everyone- There is no excuse for having any of them feel betrayed or shocked by their behavior with the changes reverted, Ted excepted. and he agreed to the whole thing as well. Wrapping the whole thing, they live in a society that approves of routine memory removal as a policy.
And the 'child marriage' (say better child engagement), was entirely arranged by other people the protagonist was rightfully terrified by. It wasn't presented as any sort of greater good, just as something he was trying to escape without an eternity of torture followed by death.
As the 'blood magic' amounted to a few transfusions, and the rest of the crimes (save copyright infringement) you listed were commited against people who were guilty of every crime they used against them, and generally a great deal more, it also lacks a great deal of credibility to call it out as horrible.
I must acknowledge the Dursleys, one can't prove they attempted to murder Harry. That said, the scenes of their behavior in the original novels warrant multiple decade prison sentences.
| Brother Bludgeon chapter 1 . 7/15/2013
I went into your reviews expecting a mixed bag, and that's what I got. So here's a mixed review to match.
This story feels like an exposé of an author who demonizes traits in characters he doesn't like, then turns around and gives those same traits to characters he does like and immediately justifies them. It's the reason I stopped reading Chunin Exam Day. It's the reason I stopped reading Partially Kissed Hero. I read all of "My Gilded Life" in advance of reading your alternate ending because I wanted to grasp the full context, otherwise I likely wouldn't have made it to the later chapters. Those stories started out interesting, thought provoking, even. And they were fun. But the fun drained away as the stories became reminiscent of level grinding for experience points in an RPG, and the interest waned as the new ideas and concepts became fewer and farther between, replaced by straw man villains and halfbaked philosophy. This is a nearly perfect attack of this author, using his own methods, no less. You powered up Dumbledore significantly beyond canon and used him to lay the smack down on a character you don't like.
But, the fact is that this really is just an attack. Not on a fictional character, but on the author that raped and mangled said character. On a real, flesh and blood person. Why? Because you needed to highlight his hypocrisy? Why? Because of some loyalty to the characters that you feel he's betrayed? My Gilded Life wasn't very good, most people can tell that just by reading it. Some people, granted, have apparently only made the connection after reading this alternate ending, but doesn't that mean that Perfect Lionheart had originally succeeded in entertaining those people.
What you did here is the literary equivalent of c***blocking. It's a dick move. And some people could argue that you only made that move because his self insert got more than 100 more reviews than your self insert Most Heinous of Crimes and more than 300 above your Hands. I know that wasn't the reason, but the argument is there.
AJT, you are bar none one of my favorite fan fiction writers. I love your stuff, I love your unique perspective. I love the fact that you can show morality without getting preachy and show a little naughtiness into a story without losing your flair for characterization, brilliant dialogue, and believable storylines. This sort of thing, this mudslinging, is beneath a writer of your quality. I eagerly await your next posting, hopefully free of any other fanfic author's work to taint it.
| treavellergirl chapter 1 . 7/10/2013
Well it certainly was a different take on the ending I love different outcomes that you never suspect
| Ari989 chapter 1 . 7/10/2013
What is this?
First of all, what gives you the right to write an alternate ending to someone else's story? It would have been one thing to do it out of admiration, but you wrote this piece out of hate and malice.
So this is, at heart, the ultimate flame for a story that was finished years ago and an author that was bullied into quitting writing. Never in all my years of reading fanfiction have I seen such a thing. Why would you bother to harbor so much hatred after so long?
And I know it's not limited to this website. I've seen what you've said about Skysaber/Lionheart over on the Spacebattle forum (you and the otherwise kind members of that website turn into truly vicious creatures at the smallest mention of Lionheart and his works).
You need to stop taking what people write in fanfiction so seriously. People (like Lionheart) write fanfiction for fun, not so they can be bullied and verbally attacked for their work.
Which brings me back to you. Why are you wasting your time trying to destroy someone else's work instead of being creative and writing you own? And I know you're a good writer, so getting this "story" on my alerts was a huge disappointment.
It's time to let Skysaber/Lionheart rest in peace, as he is most certainly among us (the fanfiction community) no more.
| guilded8472 chapter 1 . 7/10/2013
Sigh! Well after reading your story I cannot in good keeping with site rules tell you what I think of this so I'm just going to remove you from my follow list and say I hope your muse deserts you.