Reviews for Harry Potter and the Return of Heritage
Guest chapter 13 . 9/10/2024
The terrible tropes and cliches are bad enough, but I can't deal with any more of the canon rehash.
StefanInVienna chapter 44 . 9/1/2024
I very much apreciate the editing and update, well done. Hope the other books of the heritage series get the same treatment soon.
rune1806 chapter 44 . 8/31/2024
I enjoyed the story. Thanks for sharing it with us.
terrahsims chapter 1 . 8/30/2024
TROLL (G Fawkes) IN THE COMMENTS! I thought you ought to know.
Mr-Luca-Wolf chapter 1 . 8/17/2024
I love the comment under me
bballandy00 chapter 1 . 7/24/2024
I have nothing to say about the story yet but the dude commenting under me called g fawkes might be the most annoying and insufferable person i have ever met bar none
G Fawkes chapter 44 . 7/10/2024
What I just completed was the EDITED version?! Wow! (Horrified)

And it's Almanac. The Alamac is a hotel in Miami. I was going to say there was no such word. Apparently, I was wrong.
G Fawkes chapter 43 . 7/10/2024
Would people who are already IN the UK, really say "daddy's taking me to Europe"?
They already ARE IN Europe. They are standing in Europe.
England? in Europe.
Scotland? in Europe.
Ya' just get out a crayon and circle that whole little corner of the globe. Bam! Europe.
Every single person who is not actually leaving, and going somewhere further away, can say " I'm spending the summer in Europe"... and never even leave home.

(the British magicals are AT LEAST 100 years behind the rest of the world, socially. Hell, politically, its probably 200. They don't even know what an "EU" IS. They couldn't tell you if muggle England was in the EU or not! They would not designate themselves as being NOT part of Europe)
G Fawkes chapter 42 . 7/9/2024
" It doesn't do to SWELL on that which cannot be changed. "
REALLY?!
Proofread much? Ever?
G Fawkes chapter 40 . 7/9/2024
That last conversation is weird. Sirius doesn't know any more than Harry does. That should be Poppy answering Harry's questions.
G Fawkes chapter 39 . 7/8/2024
"Flagrate"
Grrrrrrr. I hate when an author doesn't give a crap enough to look up, (or remember) A spell correctly!
Wtf would 'flarigate' mean, anyway?! FLAGRATE obviously means something to do with fire! Would 'flarigate mean open the gate?
G Fawkes chapter 37 . 7/8/2024
Perhaps exuberant instead of exorbitant? Unless they really did have an expensive, lavish party.
G Fawkes chapter 34 . 7/7/2024
TWO. "What are you TWO doing here?"

I guess I internally put the 'process', or technicality, before the plot. I don''t know how anyone can write a 332K story and two sequels, if you can't keep "to, too, and two" straight? I don't intend it in a mean way. I literally cannot conceive beginning to write (which is WHY I haven't written my own) without rereading all seven books, taking more notes than would fill a book itself, having every name, spell, and incantation perfect.
PLUS perfect spelling, diction, etc. Present author excluded, I swear some people use voice dictation, spew out their fic, and don't bother to proofread what hit the page. It's THAT bad.
But then, I've been saying I was going to quit reading Harry Potter for five (?) years, now. Move on to something with substance. Maybe the Harvard Five Foot Book Shelf. or all of Shakespeare?
But I just LIKE fanfiction SO MUCH!
But that's just me.
G Fawkes chapter 33 . 7/6/2024
"Your blood will make this land in retribution for generations to come!"

What? Literally WTF?! Isn't this line important enough to get it right, so the goddamn thing makes sense?!

Make this land WHAT? There are SO MANY possible ways to FIX that sentence, I don't even know what you were TRYING to say..
G Fawkes chapter 32 . 7/6/2024
This family magic bs, striking out subconsciously is a bit much.
2,131 | « Prev Page 1 2 3 4 5 12 .. Last Next »