|Reviews for What if She Was|
| Killingdemons101 chapter 24 . 5/26
I loved your story, it's awesome. I would have never guessed it was Veronica, and now I think about it, there were subtle hints strategically laid throughout the story about it. Katherine is a lovely name by the way, though, I was kind of rooting for the baby being named Skylar. Because, you know, while Clary wasn't really Skylar, she was still an important part of her life. I thought by naming her child Skylar ,she would let that part of her live on in the world. It was just a name, but at that time, that's what she believed she was and she found amazing friends, so maybe Skylar wasn't really a bad thing in her life, and I'm not making any sense at all, am I?
Though I can understand why Clary gave her a new name. Skylar kind of also stood as a memory of what had happened, and I guess she'd want to lock it in, I don't know how to even explain it. But I understand why Clary took that choice. Also the OOC characters are adorable and awesome and I really want a Miles for me too, where can I get one? Just kidding. I'm obviously in love with Ralph.
| Donut butt chapter 7 . 11/30/2018
I don’t like Adrian kissing Skylar I like sky and Jace
| Donut butt chapter 6 . 11/30/2018
OMG can I please have another lace kiss love it! ️
| Donut butt chapter 5 . 11/30/2018
I hate Adrian he’s annoying and steeling Skylar from Jace I hope the brake up
| Donut butt chapter 4 . 11/30/2018
I love it! I hope Skylar (clary?) and Jace fall in love ️
| Donut butt chapter 3 . 11/30/2018
I love this it’s nice I just wish sky’s hair went back to red so she looked more like clary
| RSM0916 chapter 24 . 7/20/2018
Another great story! Thanks for writing it!
| Guest chapter 24 . 5/29/2018
I dont really know how to start this off so im just going to say, hi.
I loved your story so much, ive been looking for a good shadowhunters story for weeks, and you gave me a perfect one. Ive never felt so emotionally attached to the characters in a fanfiction before. I loved the story and thought it was great. Its the first story im reading that you made, and im already waiting to read more stories. I hope you still do these types of stories because i would read them all.
You might never see this since you posted this in 2013 and its 2018 but, i hope you know i loved it and cant wait to read more of your stories.
P.S- i stayed up to 1:15a.m. to finish this story... Thats how much i wanted to know what happend.
| daughterofpercabeth417 chapter 24 . 4/15/2018
Where do I even begin? This story was so incredibly amazing that words cannot describe it. For so many reasons, too. It was so well written and the plot was so perfectly detailed. I read this whole story in about a day. I laughed and cried and honestly just really loved this story! Amazing job!
| Guest chapter 24 . 4/1/2018
THAT STORY WAS FREAKING AMAZING! Best fanfiction I've read about Clace
| Puppy 17 chapter 9 . 9/6/2017
| Guest chapter 24 . 8/16/2017
How could you even end such a perfect story
| Guest chapter 24 . 2/7/2017
Omg this was the best fanfic I have ever read! You should make a book series out of it or something based on the child and the circle and Clary's parabatai! Great work!
| Guest chapter 24 . 1/30/2017
I really liked your story I just wished it didn't end so soon! If you could ever continue it I would deffinatly be your first reader
| mayagguygmail.com chapter 24 . 12/14/2016
Omg! This story was so freaking amazing! Thankb you for writing this! Just wondering, is there going to be a sequel? ️️️️️️