Disclaimer: I do not own Teen Titans or the song "If I Told You" from one of my favorite movie musical adaptations, The Wedding Singer.
Scene: A deleted scene from "Betrothed."
A couple of notes before we being:
Robin singing is in italics
Starfire singing is in bold
The two singing together is italicized and bold.
Get it? Awesome.
"Robin…if you cannot be happy for me…then perhaps you should not attend my wedding." Starfire said; a look of anger on her face.
Robin looked at her as if he had just been lanced through the heart. He barely even managed to say, "Starfire…"
She ignored his voice and walked toward her room and vanished from his sight. Robin closed his eyes and shook his head before he climbed down the side of the balcony. He dropped safely onto the ground and looked at the setting moon.
'Maybe I am too late.' Robin thought, silently cursing himself for what he had done and what he could have done.
Robin began to trudge away, dejectedly. He took one last look the window as an invisible orchestra began as Robin began to sing, "Waiting here underneath your window, hoping for some kind of sign. Every move, every tiny gesture only proves that you're not mine."
Robin took a seat by one of the trees and continued his lament, his eyes still locked on the window, "I could write you a thousand love songs, search the world for the perfect tune and rhyme but would it do when seems I'm out of time."
He let out a breath and sang out, "If I told you all the words I've yet to say, would they matter or would you simply turn and walk away? If I hold you, will you tell me I should go? Do I chance it or would it just be better not to know?"
Robin closed his eyes and let out a strained cry.
Meanwhile, Starfire had quite a bit on her mind, maybe more than he did.
Starfire looked at herself in the mirror and sang out, "Who is that girl with the perfect future? Her reflection says it all, trying hard to pretend she is eager, searching for some way to stall."
She looked back at her communicator, singing of the choice between her planet and the boy she loved, "So unsure of the road she has chosen, faced with feelings her heart should not allow. One thing is certain it seems that she cannot turn back now, if she can tell her how?"
The two, one looking at the window, the other out of the same window, let out their final plea to the other but both were unable to hear, "If I told you…"
"All the words I've yet to say," Starfire sang, hoping her real prince would hear as Robin followed, "All the words…"
"Would they matter…"
Their voices joined together, "Or would you simply turn and walk away?"
"If I hold you…"
"If I hold you…"
"Will you tell me I should go?"
"Do I chance it or would it just be better not know?"
Robin stood and began to walk away as Starfire walked back into her room.
"Would it just be better not to know…"
He took one last look as they belted out together.
"Not to know?"
Robin seemed defeated and his day only got worse when a guard grabbed him and tossed him into a cell with his friends.