I know I said that I woulnd't start another story, but this one has been bugging me for a while, so I finally decided to start it.







AnnuxKazuo(no shipping)

eventual Yami/Yuugi(Puzzleshipping)

This one has a female Yuugi in it, so don't read this one if you don't like Yuugi as a girl.

Summary: Yami's always been a player. One night, he ends up having a one night stand with Yuugi MUtou. After it, Yami thinks that's the end of it. But why can't he stop thinking about her? After learning about it, Atemu, Yami's brother, gets into a violent argument becasue of it. Atemu is Yuugi's twin brother's, Heba, boyfriend. He's angry at what his brother did, which leads to Atemu refusing to speak to his brother. When Yami tries to approach Yuugi, she tells him she just used him to ge rid of her goody two-shoes reputation. Upset, Yami confides in his friends, who tell him he's in love with her. Realizing that they're right, Yami decides to try and win her over. What will happen? Will Yuugi ever listen to Yami? Will Yami end up being the one played this time? And what will happn when Yami learns of a secret that Yuugi is keeping?

There will be yaoi and lemons in this story.

Disclaimer: I don't own Yu-Gi-Oh! or the characters. I just write about them.

Also, I would like to thank HikariTenshiYamiTenshi for letting me use thier OCs Annu and Kazou, so those two don't belong to me, either.

Hope you like it.

Lemon in this chapter

Chapter 1- A One Night Mistake

Yuugi was a little uneasy at this party. She wasn't one that would party often, but her brother had dragged her here. 'I shouldn't have come.' Yuugi thought as she scanned the crowd that was dancing.

Yuugi Moto was a somewhat shy senior at Domino High, but she was one that would also stand up for herself when she needed to.

Heba Moto, Yuugi's twin brother, had dragged her here because he knew that his boyfriend, Atemu Sennen, would be here as well, and Heba wanted to be here to be with him.

Yuugi, however, was single and really didn't like the idea of coming, but Heba had dragged her here anyway.

'Heba is so dead for all this.' Yuugi thought.

Across the room, Yami Sennen, who was known as the school whore as he slept with almost every girl he came across that resulted in one night stands, was scanning the crowd.

'Humph. I've had everyone here.' Yami thought.

Yami was bored and knew that he shouldn't have come, but wondered if maybe there would be someone knew that he could bed that he hadn't before.

'I'm leaving.' Yami thought. He turned to leave when he noticed Yuugi. 'Hmm. Yuugi Moto. There's someone new.' Yami thought. He smirked before making his way over to Yuugi. "Hello, Yuugi." Yami said.

Yuugi turned and was surprised to see Yami. "Hello, Yami." Yuugi said.

Yuugi had only admitted it to her best friend, Annu, but Yuugi had a major crush on Yami even with his reputation.

"I didn't' expect to see you at a party like this." Yami said.

"I wasn't going to, but Heba wanted to come since Atemu would be here and dragged me here, too." Yuugi answered.

"Then where is he at?" Yami asked.

"I don't know. Probably off making out with Atemu somewhere." Yuugi answered.

"Well, it's shame that he left you here all alone." Yami said. 'Better for me.' Yami thought. "Do you want to dance?" Yami asked.

Before Yuugi could voice a response, Yami grabbed her and dragged Yuugi out onto the dance floor.

"Well, I guess Yami found his next bedmate." Malik said.

Malik, Ryou, Tea, and Kazuo, all of whom were Yami's friends, watched as Yami danced with Yuugi.

"I wish that Yami would cut this out. He's not going to be happy if he keeps bed hopping like he does." Kazuo said.

"Well, you know Yami. That's all he does. That poor girl will have a one night stand with him and then he'll leave her." Tea said.

"I feel sorry for Yuugi. She doesn't deserve this. She's a real sweet girl." Ryou said.

"Maybe, but Yami doesn't care. He never cares about the girls that he sleeps with." Malik said.

The four friends hated what Yami did, but knew there was nothing they could do to stop him.

Later, Yami and Yuugi found themselves back at Yuugi's house in her room.

Yami kissed Yugi passionately as he pushed her back against the door. Yami started to kiss and lick her neck and Yuugi moaned.

Yami had easily won Yuugi over his with his charm and had easily convinced her to take him back to her place.


Yami easily took off Yuugi's shirt and threw it to the side before he took off her bra, too. Yami pushed Yuugi down onto her bed and lend cupped one of her breasts before he took the nipple into his mouth and started to suck on it.

Yuugi cried out at that.

Yami sucked until the nipple was hard before he turned his attention to the other nipple.

Once he was done, Yami took off Yuugi's pants and underwear. 'Hmm. Rather beautiful.' Yami thought.

Yami took off his own clothes before he lay down on top of Yuugi and kissed her again.

If Yuugi had been thinking straight, she would have put an end to this, but Yuugi's common sense had been thrown out the window as she turned to jelly under Yami's touches.

Yami spread Yuugi's legs out before positioning himself between her legs. Yami took the lube that he carried with out before he slicked up his member. He then positioned himself at Yuugi's entrance before he thrust into her in one fluid motion.

Yuugi cried out at that since she had been a virgin.

Yami hadn't known that she was a virgin, but he didn't mind. He pulled out until only the tip if his member was left inside of her before he thrust back in hard.

Yuugi reached up and grasped Yami's shoulders, crying out with each hard thrust.

Yami was enjoying himself more than he usually did when he had sex with a girl. He continued with a fast, hard pace.

Yami's actions caused Yuugi to reach her end as she came, crying out, "YAMI!"

Yami felt Yuugi's walls clamp down on him and he came as well, crying out, "YUUGI!" He released into Yuugi before he collapsed on top of her.


Both were sweating and panting as they recovered.

It still hadn't dawned on Yuugi to use common sense, but it was too late by now.

Yami, however, was far from satisfied and started to move within her again.

Yuugi could only go along with Yami as he continued to have sex with her.

The sunlight streamed into the room, and the warmth woke Yuugi up.

Yuugi opened her amethyst eyes and sat up, wincing at the soreness she felt. Looking down, Yuugi was horrified to realize that she was naked.

The night before came to her like a beam.

"OH, no, no, no!" Yuugi cried.

Yami was gone, which wasn't unusual. He always left before his one night stands woke up.

Yuugi quickly scrambled out of bed and grabbed a robe before leaving the room and looking into her brother's room.

Heba was fast asleep.

Yuugi noticed the clothes strewn in the floor and knew that Atemu had come here last night since Heba's room was always neat and clean.

Yuugi went back into her room and showered and got into some clothes before going downstairs, feeling like a slut.

Atemu was in the kitchen, making breakfast. "Oh. Morning, Yuugi. I hope that you don't me making breakfast." Atemu said.

"No. I don't care." Yuugi said, collapsing into a chair before he buried her face in her arms she crossed on the table.

Atemu frowned and turned off the stove. He walked over and sat down by Yuugi. "Yuugi, you okay?" Atemu asked.

"No. I did something really stupid last night." Yuugi said.

"Come on, Yuugi. Leaving a party early isn't stupid. Heba shouldn't have brought you anyway." Atemu said, rubbing Yuugi's back gently.

Atemu already saw Yuugi as a sister. He had first gotten to know her when he started dating Heba a year and a half earlier and was very close to her now.

Yuugi raised her hand and turned to look at Atemu.

Atemu was startled to see tears falling down Yuugi's cheeks. She looked utterly lost. "Yuugi, what is it? What happened?" Atemu asked, wiping the tears from Yuugi's face.

"Atemu, I did what had to be the stupidest thing I could have ever done." Yuugi said.

"Yuugi, what? Did something happen at that party?" Atemu asked.

"Yeah. I-I slept with your brother." Yuugi said.

Yami's eyes widened. "Yami?! You slept with Yami?!" Atemu exclaimed.

Yuugi nodded. "He came onto me at the part. I should have known better, but I danced with him anyway and then we ended up back here and-" Yuugi stopped as she started crying.

Atemu reached out and pulled Yuugi into a hug. He would deal with his brother later. Yuugi needed him at the moment.

"So, was she any good?" Bakura asked.

"Actually, yes. Better than any other time, actually." Yami said.

Marik whistled. "You landed one. A lot of guys have tried to seduce her, but you're the first one that managed." Marik said.

"Come on, guys. Knock it off." Tea said.

"What? Not like it's your sex life we're talking." Bakura said.

Tea glared at him.

"Enough is enough though. You've talked about it so let's forget about it." Tristan agreed. He didn't like Yami's bed hopping either, but there wasn't much that he could do about it.

"Come on. Let's go out." Seto said.

The group stood up and started to eave when Atemu came in.

"Yami, we need to talk." Atemu said.

"Later. We're going out." Yami said as he started to leave.

Atemu grabbed Yami by the shoulder and slammed him into the wall with such force that the pictures on the wall shook.

"Atemu!" Seto shouted, shocked at his normally calm cousin's actions.

"You listen to me you slut." Atemu said in a dangerous tone.

Yami, for the first time in his life, was scared of his brother.

"I know what you did to Yuugi, and I have had it with you. Until now, I've managed to look past all of the bed hopping at that you do, but you crossed the line this time." Atemu said.

"It's not your concern." Yami spat.

"Yes, it is. You see, Yuugi is more than just my boyfriend's twin sister. She is also my friend, not to mention the fact that I look at her like a sister. You used her, and I have had it." Atemu said angrily.

"Damn it, Atemu! Let go! I'm your brother!" Yami shouted.

"No, your not. You're nothing but a whore who sleeps with any bitch, but you crossed the line. As far as I'm concerned, I have no brother! You're nothing to me! I don't ever want to see your sorry face again!" Atemu growled.

Yami's eyes widened. "You can't be serious." Yami said.

Atemu let go of him. "I'm very serious. As far as I'm concerned, I have no brother." Atemu said. He turned to leave.

"Atemu, wait!" Yami said, grabbing his brother by the shoulder.

Atemu whirled around and punched Yami right in the face, sending Yami crashing into the table. "You're not my brother, so leave me the hell alone! Come near Yuugi again, and I'll do worse than that." Atemu said before he staled out of the mansion, slamming the door behind him.

Everyone was shocked. They all knew that Atemu hated what his brother did to all of the girls, but they didn't think it would escalate this.

Yami held his bloody nose although he barely registered it.

Yami and Atemu were twin brothers and had always been there for each other. Regardless of what the other did, they were always there for each other. Now, with Atemu's words, Yami felt his heart break and realized he may have lost his relationship with his brother permanently.

"Yami, you okay?" Kazuo asked, kneeling down beside him.

Yami didn't respond because he was too upset to.

"Just leave." Yami said before getting up and going upstairs.

"Wait!" Joey said, starting to go after Yami, but Seto stopped him.

"Don't, puppy. It won't help." Seto said.

"I guess the consequences of Yami's bed hopping have finally come." Ryou said.

"Yeah, but I so didn't expect this." Malik said.

"So, you slept with Yami Sennen?" Annu asked, just to make sure that she understood.

Yuugi nodded. "I know that I shouldn't have, but I couldn't help it. I'm so stupid." Yuugi said, covering her face with her hands.

"No, you're not stupid, Yuugi. Stop saying that." Annu said.

"It was a mistake, and I can't believe that I did that." Yuugi said.

"Yuugi, you've had a crush on him for years. You let your emotions get in the way." Annu said.

"Yeah, but now he'll be coming up to me and saying that it was just a one-time thing." Yuugi said.

Annu smiled at her friend. "Don't be so hard on yourself, Yuugi. It'll be okay." Annu said.

"I don't even want to know what grandpa will say when he finds out." Yuugi said.

"He doesn't have to. No one has to. Yami doesn't go around bragging about the girls he gets except to his friends, and they don't say a word. No one else has to know about this." Annu said.

"I just don't know if I can deal with this right now." Yuugi said.

"You can and you will. If you need to talk to me, fine. Just talk. Don't keep it in." Annu said.

"Thanks, Annu." Yuugi said. She looked at Annu and said, "Any luck on finding the courage to ask Kazuo out?"

Annu blushed.

Yuugi knew of Annu's like of Kazuo and had encouraged Annu to ask him out.

"No, not yet. I'm not sure if I should. I might at some point." Annu said.

Yuugi smiled. "You should.' Yuugi said. 'At least one of us could be happy.' Yuugi thought.

"Damn it! I can't believe that he did this!" Heba growled.

"Believe me. I know, and he knows I'm angry." Atemu said.

"I swear that if he comes near my sister, he's dead." Heba said.

"You're not going to kill him, Little Star." Atemu said.

"Atemu, I-" Heba started.

"Heba, you're not going to kill him because I am going to do that." Atemu said.

Heba sighed before sitting on Atemu's lap. "What are we going to do?" Heba asked, leaning into Atemu.

Atemu wrapped his arms around Heba and hugged him. "I don't know, but I do know that I will be staying here a lot more. At least until my parents get back from their trip." Atemu said.

"You don't have to." Heba said.

"I know, but I want to. I'll have to go back home when my parents get back in two weeks, though." Atemu said.

"Yuugi and I will be fine, Atemu. Yami's the one who you should worry about." Heba said.

"I'm not. He's going to regret this." Atemu said.

Yami looked out his window as Atemu's words replayed in his head. 'I can't believe this. Atemu's angry just because I slept with Yuugi.' Yami thought.

Yami wouldn't admit it, but he hated being a player. He just didn't want to trust a girl.

Yami flipped onto his back and touched his tender nose. "Atemu's got one hell of a punch. Next time, I'll need to avoid it." Yami murmured.

Yami figured that he would wait until Monday to talk to his brother. By then, Atemu might have calmed down.

Until then, Yami figured he could call up one of his old one night stands for the night.

Hope that you liked it. Let me know if I should keep this story the way it is or if I should redo it.

Next chapter has Yuugi and Yami confronting each other and Yami having to admit something he thought he would never admit.