Disclaimer: I own nothing. Wouldn't mind owning Mark Salling because he is just too hot for words but alas I only own the story. Quinn isn't pregnant but still joined Glee to keep an eye on Finn and Rachel. Quinn quit the Cheerios for Glee. Very Original character.

"HOW COULD YOU HAVE KEPT THIS FROM ME FOR 10 YEARS RACHEL? I HAD A RIGHT TO KNOW. YOU HAD NO RIGHT TO KEEP THIS FROM ME!" Noah Eli Puckerman screamed at the brown eyed beauty in front of him. The tears streaming down her face tugged at his heart. She still looked beautiful even after all the years and all he wanted to do was pull her into his arms and kiss her senseless. But that was not an option now. She had kept this from him and he wanted to know why. She owed him that. "WHY DIDN'T YOU TELL ME?" Noah yelled

"DON'T YOU DARE TURN THIS AROUND ON ME NOAH PUCKERMAN! I TRIED TO TELL YOU BUT DO YOU REMEMBER WHAT YOU SAID TO ME THAT DAY YOU BROKE UP WITH ME? THAT YOU COULDN'T BE TIED DOWN TO ONE GIRL AND DID I HONESTLY THINK THAT WE WOULD LAST AFTER HIGHSCHOOL. I LOVED YOU NOAH AND YOU BROKE MY HEART. SO DON'T YOU DARE THINK THAT YOU HAD ANY RIGHT!" Rachel screamed at him, crossing her arms over her chest fuming. He had no right to be here. She had waited for him for years and now when she had finally made the decision to let him go, he shows up. She still wanted him, her body ached for him but things between them were over. He had made that perfectly clear their last day of high school.

"I don't want to fight with you Noah. But you made your decisions all on your own and I made mine. You made it perfectly clear what you thought about our relationship back in high school. I think you should leave." Rachel stated moving away from him towards her apartment door opening it waiting for him to move away from her. He was standing to close to her for comfort. She didn't know what she would do if he didn't leave now.

"No. I'm not leaving Berry until you tell me why. You owe me that." Noah stated pushing the apartment door closed.

"I owe you nothing Noah. NOW GET OUT."

"No. I want to know the reason that you kept my daughter from me for ten years." Noah sneered glaring down at her. "And I am not leaving until you tell me why."

Tears streamed down her face as Rachel hung her head down in defeat. Glancing up at him, she saw pain and fear in his eyes. There was a flicker of something else but he quickly masked it as he pushed away from her walking to the couch, flopping down on it. Taking a deep breath she followed him and timidly sat on the edge of the couch next to him.

"You win. It started on our 3 year anniversary.…"