Author's note: A recent writing exercise prompted me to write about destiny. An option was to have two characters from an existing piece of my original writing engage in a dialogue about it. In homage to the recent passing of JD Salinger, my character will be speaking to none other than Catcher in the Rye's own Holden Caulfield. I'm also going to conceal my character's actual name for demented reasons known only to me. Let's call her "Margaret" for now.

Dialogue of Destiny

Seated on parallel wooden benches in the echoing open hall of a grand urban train station, Margaret is no longer able to ignore the penetrating glare narrowly skimming her shoulder, fired from a bench directly in front of her. Normally, she would retreat into the safe cavern of her shyness around strangers or move seats altogether, but she senses something troubled in this young man's gaze akin to her own melancholy. He doesn't appear threatening; he is quite clean-cut and looking smart in a well-tailored overcoat. It is only the red hunting hat that he dons that signals a mild alarm that something about him might be off.

Overwhelmed in fearful curiosity as to what his attention may be directed to at her side, Margaret summons the confidence to speak.

"Are you all right?"

Perhaps the ear flaps of his hunting cap muffle the sound from reaching his notice.

"Are you okay?"

The young man's eyes dart up with a start as he recognizes he's being addressed.


"Sorry, I know I'm being random, but I was just wondering if there's something near me that's bothering you. Hopefully, it's not me."

"How'd you be bothering me just sitting there?" he notes, trying to affect a blank expression, though unable to conceal an innocent bewilderment.

"I don't know." Margaret reddens, feeling silly that she brought this all upon herself. "I guess I might remind of you someone you don't like."

Holden takes his turn to flush. Evidently conscious of his hat, he slides it back genteelly off his short, unexpectedly graying hair with his left hand as he extends his right over the back-rest for Margaret to shake.

"Holden. Nice to meet you."


"Sorry if I creeped you out and all. It's nothing to do with you. I'm not a madman or anything, I was only looking at the graffiti." He gestures to a word carved in the wood a mere couple inches from her right arm. "It's nothing to do with you."

Margaret interprets this repetition as a polite way of telling her to butt out. "No, I'm sorry. I didn't mean to pry."

"No, don't worry," Holden replies, seeming to pick up on her embarrassment. "I don't think you're being nosy or anything. I shouldn'ta been looking like I was staring at you and all. I mean, I don't mean to be rude."

Seeking to get past this mutual awkwardness, Margaret rotates her head and leans forward to better read the carving. "Destino," she reads aloud. Huh.

"Means 'destiny,' I guess." When Margaret doesn't speak, Holden nervously rambles on. "You know, I hate graffiti. I hate messing up stuff that's supposed to look nice. Just the idea that some phony would sit there and have a goddam knife to pull out and slice into this nice varnished wood that's here for everybody else too depresses the hell outta me." On observing her furrowing brow: "Pardon me, ma'am. Excuse my language."

Conscious of her expression, Margaret tries to shake it off flippantly. "Oh! No, no. Not at all. Takes a lot to offend me, trust me. I was just thinking about what you said. I totally understand."

Holden continues, "It's just that I see this stuff everywhere, and it depresses me, if you want to know the truth. I saw a goddam 'F*** you' written on a wall in my little sister's school, for Chrissake. I hate that. It's lousy to write something like that in a kid's school."

Margaret grins inwardly at Holden's critical cursing about cursing, and she finds her interest piqued by this complex youth approximately half her age. It seems he might be game for waxing philosophical for a brief while, at least to kill time.

"Well, I'm not a fan of graffiti either, but you have to admit this is a nicer form of it. I mean, maybe the person wasn't 'phony' at all, but seriously contemplating what that word means. Maybe they were celebrating that their destiny had just been fulfilled, or praying so."

"Believing in destiny is phony. There isn't any such thing, and anyone who tells you otherwise is a goddam phony bastard himself."

"You're quite cynical for your age! I take it you see yourself as the master of your own fate, then?"

"I don't think I'm the master of anything. We're all stuck falling through this phony world, laughing at jokes we don't even think are funny and taking an exam or doing work that we're brainwashed to believe is important and stuff, and for what? Money? Reputation? Pay a dime to dance with a pretty girl? None of it adds up to a pile of beans when all's said and done. We work ourselves to the bone to end up dead, and then what? We can't take it with us. No, I'm no master of anything." Just then, Holden looks off into a realm of thought invisible to Margaret and quiets to almost a whisper. "I'd like to be. I think I could be. If I could just catch those crazy kids when they came falling. I could be the master of that. I really think I could."

Trying her best at interpretation without being too invasive, Margaret asks, "You'd like to help those that can't help themselves. The ones that Destiny hasn't been kind to?"

"I know it sounds crazy, like I'm some sort of madman and maybe I am, but I can't stop thinking about those kids." He raises his red hat back to his head as though unconsciously and pulls it over his ears snugly. "Goddam graffiti."

Though she has no clue what kids he's talking about nor where they're falling from or why, empathetic soul that she is, Margaret attempts to soothe Holden by relating the best way she can. "I feel that way, too, sometimes. That life can be random, and we just have to keeping rolling with the current with our heads above water as best we can. But overall I think that flow might still be taking us somewhere, with or without our consent. Or not. I feel for others' disillusionment, too, and would like to think someone would be there to catch me if I fell."

She doesn't expect it when Holden looks her directly in the eye just then.

"Too late," he shakes his head. "But don't worry, because it's too late for me too."

Margaret is perplexed at the seeming sage quality in this kid. "How so?"

"We've grown up. We can't ride the carousel anymore."

Margaret lowers her eyes. "I don't think we should give up on ourselves just yet. I'm not giving up, anyways. I think Fate has something in store for me yet."

"So you think you can still do anything about it?"

"Yeah. Well, I'd like to think so. I mean, I do believe in free will. More than just tossing my hands up to the skies and saying, 'Ah well. So be it.'"

"You'd sounded more like you believed in destiny before." Holden is looking at her skeptically now.

Before he can size her up as a phony, she insists, "I do. I guess I've just always figured we still operate 'freely' within that larger structure already put in place—by God, or whatever you might or apparently might not believe in. What I'm trying to say is that I personally think we have an ultimate destiny, even if the paths we take to get there and the experiences along the way are for the most part controlled by us. There might be those 'little events' planted here and there for a purpose, then, like occasional guideposts or guardrails to keep us on track."

Peering at her stoically from beneath his cap, Holden does not look convinced.

Margaret presses on with the proverbial college-try. "I remember reading somewhere, in someone's blog, that that was their theory on deja-vu, that what we see that feels so familiar are actually signs that we're on target…like on some level we've already lived out our destiny, and what we see as deja-vu is the playback, in brief clips, to show us that what we're doing, at that exact point in time, is exactly what we're supposed to be doing and where."

"I don't know what a 'blog' is, but that's an interesting thought. It really is, no kidding. I get those sometimes, too, those deja-vus, but I don't tell anybody about them or anything because those Pencey crooks'd think I was a damn sissy and knock my lights out. They really would. But still, I get them. The deja-vus, I mean. I figure they only mean that I'm crazy and all. Like my brain is on the fritz."

"I don't know if we'll ever really know what they are, but I think it's safe to say they're not a sign of insanity. Whatever those 'Pencey crooks' say, it happens to everyone, even them, whoever they are."

"They don't matter anymore. Never did, really. You'll probably think I'm crazy for saying this and all, but it's my kid sister that's got everything figured out, if you really want to know the truth." Holden instantly appears to glow from within at the mention. "That kid kills me, she really does. You would like her. I mean, it's not like she's perfect or anything, but she's really likable. Old Phoebe's the real deal."

Margaret smiles kindly at the sibling sentimentality. "So, do you think Phoebe would believe in anything like Destiny? Does she not need you to catch her?"

The corners of his mouth turn down a perceptible degree. "All I do is let her down; she doesn't need me for anything. And she doesn't need to rely on Destiny or anything because she'll make her own. She'll grab the goddam reins of that carousel horse and get it to race around the other way. I really think she could do it, too. If she wanted to and all."

"Holden, if you can believe that of anyone, you can't be a total fatalist. Surely you can believe it of yourself, then."

Holden eyes Margaret up and down and shifts in his seat, and for a moment she wonders if he finds her attractive. There's something innocent yet worldly in those eyes that tells her she isn't the first older woman he's been intimate with, conversationally or otherwise.

"Old Phoebe," he says, ignoring Margaret's insight. "She kills me. She really does. If I could stuff it all and put it behind a pane of glass, I'd do it. I would. That's the problem with Destiny, you know. She moves life forward, closer to being older and supposedly wiser and all that crap. No, we're all just tumbling through space, even Old Phoebe. Some'll get a softer landing than others, is all."

Holden does not so much as jolt a fraction of a millimeter when the loud speaker unexpectedly blares its announcement of a train ready to depart its platform. Margaret, conversely, is thrown from the jumbling and intersecting thoughts coursing through her mind in the wake of Holden's words, the speaker's static-y proclamation slicing through her reflection.

"Oh my God." She leaps to standing. "My train. Holden, I have to go."

Margaret knows she needs to flee with hyper-speed to make her train, yet the morose energy surrounding Holden is compelling.

Holden, young gentleman that he is, likewise rises onto his feet and removes his hat with a modest bow. "Ma'am."


"Margaret. Meeting you just now has been sort of like—"

"Destiny. I know. Holden?"

He extends his right hand out again for her to shake. She makes a motion to meet it when the loud speaker bombards them again. Distracted from thought, she operates on instinct and embraces him firmly. On reluctantly disconnecting, she sways back and, on pivoting on her heel toward the direction of her platform, she rewinds the movement only to seize the red hat out of Holden's hand. Reshaping it with her fist, she finds solace in the body heat it has retained before affixing it back on Holden's head.

On resuming her pivot, she turns her head counter to the spin to ask again, "Holden?"


"Catch me. If you can."

Holden sucks at his lower lip for a second. "I'll try. I really will."

He offers Margaret a quasi-salute before she turns and melds into the masses that carry her like a current toward her next destination.

[Rest in peace, Mr. Salinger.

Find peace in unrest, Holden (you, too, "Margaret").]