I sat alone in my living room, waiting for Quinn. Tonight was going to be our night, it was Halloween and Finn and Kurt were hosting a horror-movie-marathon at their place. The invite said to wear costumes, Quinn got the idea that she should be an angel, while I be a devil. It was a cute idea, and it would be the perfect way for Quinn and I to come out as a couple, arriving at the party together, in costumes that would be designated for a pair. Finally I heard the doorbell ring; I answered the door and welcomed Quinn inside. The moment the door closed her lips were on mine, the kiss was gentle and longing, we hadn't had the chance to kiss for days. Being in cheerios made Quinn much too busy, but I didn't complain, I loved being around her, even if it was only for a little while at a time.
"I missed you." Quinn stated, smiling at me. "You have our costumes, right?"
"Yeah, upstairs." I replied, and kissed her again. "I missed you too." We went up to my room, Quinn had me promise not to get dressed for the party until she got there. I went into my closet and pulled out both of the costumes, then handed Quinn hers. She looked at me with a large smile, she seemed ecstatic.
"I'm so excited." She said. She turned around and started to walk away. "I'll change in the bathroom, you can change here."
"Okay." I said, and closed my door behind her. As I was changing a million different thoughts were flying at, firstly I wondered why I had let Quinn talk me into such a short, tight costume. Second, I was curious as to how the glee club would react to Quinn and I being together, as far as everyone knew we were enemies. As distant on the food chain as two could get, yet here we were, somehow we had fallen in love, and I definitely wasn't arguing.
I finished pulling on my red-sequin dress; it was sleeveless and hugged all of my curves tightly. I put on the two fingerless gloves; they were adorned with red sequins as well. Then came my red heels, they weren't as shiny or flashy as the rest of my costume, but they did complement it quite nicely. Lastly I put on my devil horns, then I laid back on my bed, waiting for Quinn. She entered my room a few moments later, and I had to say, she truly did look like an angel. She had on a short-sleeved, flowy white dress that went down to her knees, the fabric was kind of sheer, I could see the underwear she wore beneath it if I was really looking, something I hadn't noticed when we bought it. She had on shimmering gold heels, which matched her halo. And finally, on her back was a set of feathered white wings. In one word, Quinn looked breathtaking.
"Wow, you look really stunning." I told her. She sat down next to me on the bed, and grabbed my hand, locking our fingers together.
"Thanks, Rach. So do you." She replied, licking her lips. I noticed a lustful shine in her eye; I couldn't blame her though, seeing as I was also extremely turned on right now. "Do you wanna just…. Skip the party?"
"What? But, Quinn, I thought tonight was the night. We were going to come out to the club, remember?" I asked.
"Well, I know, but we can do that some other time, I really just want to be with you tonight. Alone." Quinn said, placing a hand on my knee. "I promise we'll tell them, soon. Just not tonight, I've really missed being with you. Besides, tonight can be "the night", in another way." She smiled at me, I could tell she was coming up with a plan, and sadly, I had an idea that knew what it was.
"What is it?" I asked, rolling my eyes. I loved Quinn, but sometimes she kind of scared me. "We've already had our first time together, Quinn."
"I know, but we've never played a game together."
"Game? What kind of game? Like with toys? You know I don't own anything like that."
"No, not with toys, Rach. Just let me go out to my car, I'll be back in a minute. Stay here." Before I could stop her she was already on her way out.
"Your car, really? You planned this?" I yelled at her, I didn't know if she had heard me, not that it mattered. I couldn't believe she had been planning this; I sighed and waited impatiently for her return. Soon she appeared outside the doorway of my bedroom, both hands behind her back. "What are you holding?"
"Close your eyes." She said, she looked absolutely giddy, more excited than I had ever seen her. It was cute, but I was scared, I knew we were about to play a sex game, something I had never done before, and it was frightening me.
"No, Quinn, just show me what's behind you back."
"Rach, close your eyes. You'll love it, I promise."
"What if I don't love it?"
"You will, trust me." We kept going back and forth like this for awhile; finally I gave in, closing my eyes. I heard Quinn walk closer to the bed, then I heard a click, and then another one, with something cold around my wrist. My eyes shot open, surely enough, she had one of my arms chained to the bed.
"No! Quinn, I don't want to play this!" I yelled.
"Please play with me, it'll be fun. You're just nervous."
"You've chained me to my bed! I have the right to be nervous!" Quinn climbed on top of me, and locked her lips with mine, kissing me passionately. I kissed back, putting my free hand on her neck. She pulled out and looked down at me.
"You trust me, don't you, Rachel?" She asked, giving me pleading eyes.
"I-I guess so." I replied with a sigh. Why couldn't I say no to her?
"Yay! Stay still." She commanded, I did so, and she hooked my other arm to my bed. Now I was stuck, I couldn't take back my decision to "play" with her, but by now the idea intrigued me, I was getting excited, or maybe it was just me feeding off of all of Quinn's energy. As soon as I was locked in place she got up from the bed, then looked down at me, her voice in a whisper. "You have to play along." She said, picking up a book from my bookshelf, opening it to a random page. She stared at the page, it truly looked like she was studying what was inside, I was confused. She raised her voice back to a normal level. "Rachel Barbra Berry, a very sinful soul. What am I to do with you?" She put the book down.
"I don't know." I replied, shakily. She gave a small laugh.
"You see, Rachel, I would love to let you through my gates. Heaven would be happy to have a pretty girl like you, but you're so bad, I don't know if I can. Perhaps if I give you a small punishment I can let you in, but only if you learn your lesson."
"I'm sorry, but what exactly did I do?" I asked, not entirely capturing how she could "punish" me. Especially when she looked so amazing, when I knew she was here to pleasure me.
"Silly girl." She said, climbing back on top of me. "You see these chains, well; they're there to hold you down. You have a problem with temptation, Miss Berry, you give in so easy. I'm here to teach you a lesson, to tempt you into submission. You may even go insane from it."