So I want to apologize for this one because I tried to do it traditionally like only write in the song time NOOOOOPE. And it just wouldn't write itself no matter how many times I listened to the song. They do get better after this.

Reason it's written this way: The song just seemed to have three personalities in it. So I wrote this from Sam's POV but used the lyrics to give each boy their personality.

Warnings: Auish, Questionable con, oral sex, swearing.

Pairing-Sam/Puck/Dave –suggested by SouthernHemmy

Song- 'Believe'- Breaking Benjamin

Disclaimer: I do not own glee Fox does. I do not own 'Believe' Braking Benjamin does.

The party was like any party loud music and underage drinking. Another football cheerio celebration and hell they had earned it. It was kind of strange without Quinn, Santana, and Brittany but it wasn't like he was looking for them. No he was looking for Puck who had wandered off a while ago. Sam was only buzzed he wasn't about to stumble to the motel blind drunk. Maybe it wasn't a good idea to go home at all. He finally got a night to be a teenager and he was being mildly responsible. He stumbled upstairs to think about where Puck had gone. The music dimmed a bit but still pounded below him. Maybe that was the only reason he ever heard them.

Don't tread the water
Just stay still
I'll not be bothered
By you until
I'm picking sides
And pulling the strings

Puck was leaning against a dresser head back as he moaned. Sam was a bit surprised he was sure Lauren had Puck on a chastity leash or something. He was going to leave him to it till Puck started talking. "Shit Karofsky you suck cock like a pro." Sam blinked, alright, either he was drunker then he thought or if what he heard was true Puck and Karofsky were. "I might just be persuaded to forgive ya if your mouth is this good all the time.

I'm living lies
And shedding the skin
I'm open wide
And letting you in
I'm wronging rights

"Fuck you Puckerman." Wow that really was Karofsky down there. Sam leaned over and knocked over a basket. Both teens looked at him. Karofsky shot up and went to walk away.

"Where the hell do you think you're going?" Puck growled fisting the larger teens shirt. "You're not done apologizing yet. Sam either shut the door or get out."

"Let go Puckerman you said no one would come up here." The panic on his face kind of tugged at Sam's heart strings.

Believe
I don't care what you want
I just want mine
Shut up
Smart little bitch

"On your knees and finish your apology." Puck growled.

"Alright Puck I think you've had a little too much." Sam said approaching them. Karofsky was a jerk but that didn't give Puck any right to force him into anything.

"Shove it Evans he was just fine with sucking my cock till you came along." Puck snapped.

I don't need lies
I don't care what you want
I just want mine

"Puck just because he said yes doesn't mean he can't say no."

"I don't need any favors from you." Sam turned his attention to Karofsky. The hell? Sam was trying to be the good guy. Dave's lips were red and swollen from having them around Puck's dick.

"Shit this blows. And not even in the good way." Puck gave Karofsky a shove. Apparently intoxicated and not expecting it he fell. Sam rushed to ease his fall and ended up under the bigger teen. Puck was laughing above them.

"Damnit Puck you're not usually a mean drunk." Sam growled as they worked to right themselves. They were both kneeling. Sam went to glare up at Puck and came face to uhhh dick with Puck's, well yeah. Wow there was a reason the girls sang his praises.

"You know I always wondered if those big lips of yours were good at something." Puck stroked himself and Sam licked his lips.

Get up
Force it to fit
Confined inside

"Suck blondie." Sam looked up he always had a thing for dominate partners. Quinn and Santana were perfect examples. He hadn't been with anyone in a while and Puck's command had put the thought there. "Come on one of you. It's been to fucking long."

"Well it would be helping a bro out." Sam replied glancing toward Karofsky before leaning forward to run his tongue up Puck's length. They both seemed shocked by his actions but who cared.

Don't pull me under
Into the deep
I often wonder
How it should be

He was getting into it when a warm body settled closer to his and Dave was taking what he couldn't fit into his own mouth. Puck groaned above them clutching at the top of the dresser. Sam pulled off and sought to kiss Dave around Puck's manhood. If he was doing this he was doing this his way.

I'm picking sides
And pulling the strings
I'm living lies
And shedding the skin
I'm open wide
And letting you
I'm wronging rights

They moved toward the tip together and Sam straddled Dave's thigh. Dave moaned into their kiss as Sam rocked against him. He pulled away. "I'll give you a choice. Suck Puck and I'll do you or suck me and I'll take care of Puck. As it to answer Dave took Puck into his mouth.

Believe
I don't care what you want
I just want mine
Shut up
Smart little bitch
I don't need lies
I don't care what you want
I just want mine
Get up
Force it to fit
Confined inside

Sam moved away and worked on freeing Dave from his jeans. Dave moaned around Puck which made Puck moan above them. Sam couldn't really admire Dave with such little light so he sized him up with his tongue followed by his lips.

Sam wasn't surprised when Puck came before either of them Sam didn't know how long they'd been at it before he stumbled in. "Thanks slut." Was all he said as he tucked himself away and left. Dave moved to push him off. Sam just sucked harder gripping Dave's thighs with a moan. He'd gotten a taste of Dave and he wasn't going to stop.

I don't care what you want
I just want mine
I don't care what you want
I just want mine
Shut up
Smart little bitch
I don't need lies
I don't care what you want
I just want mine
Get up
Force it to fit
Confined inside
My dead eyes

Dave came with a low groan Sam had little choice but to swallow. He sat up licking his lips Dave refused to look at him. Sam frowned and placed a hand on his thigh. "Dave?"

"Just leave." Sam felt stung by the hollow sound in the other teens voice.

"We won't tell if you won't." Sam said standing up still painfully hard in his jeans. All he got was a stiff nod. Sam left the room really confused. He had no idea what he'd walked in on and no idea what had went wrong. He'd chosen Karofksy's side when Puck had wanted to force him back into a blow job. Then Karofsky had acted like he'd just been forced.

Maybe if he could collect Puck the other gleek would let him crash at his house. Neither of them had drove so if he got the go ahead maybe he would indulge enough to drink those dead looking hazel eyes out of his mind.