Summary: The team's latest case resembles the plot of a Sue Grafton novel, and, not surprisingly, McGee is the one to make the connection. Now, in order to solve it, they actually have to read the book. (I might end up using all the books in the series for this. *grin* Let the fun begin!)
NCIS Special Agent Timothy McGee rubbed his temples tiredly. This case was draining on all of them, even Gibbs, who seemed to be able to run solely on coffee and adrenaline.
The current case they were working on involved a female petty officer named Nicole Smith, who was out on parole, having believed to have killed her divorce lawyer husband eight years ago. Now she was serving in the U.S. Navy, but staying on American soil, since she was on leave. It seemed like an open-and-shut case, especially since she'd been convicted, but Nicole swore she was innocent. It helped that another body had turned up—one belonging to one of her husband's old flames—while she was serving time in prison. The case reminded McGee of something he'd read . . .
Suddenly the name of a Sue Grafton novel featuring a female private eye flashed in his mind, along with a brief summary of the book. Trust the McGeek to come up with that. Better yet, it could help with the case.
McGee sat up straight in his desk and said, "Boss, I got something!"
Immediately Gibbs jerked to attention. "Will it help?"
"Uh, yeah, I think so."
"What d'ya got?"
"Well, it's just an idea . . ." He rapidly explained the plan. To his surprise, Gibbs looked thoughtful, taking sips of Starbucks coffee as he thought it over. "Okay."
"What?" shrieked Tony from his desk, where he'd been eavesdropping on the conversation. "You have got to be kidding. Remember the last time we had a case linked to one of McGee's books?"
Beside him, Ziva nodded agreement, looking up from where she'd been staring over DiNozzo's shoulder at the senior field agent's computer screen.
"But it's not my book this time, Tony," McGee pointed out.
He relented. "Okay, fine. I guess I'll go along with it."
"Great," Tim said. He looked at Gibbs. "Should we invite Abby, Ducky, and Palmer?"
"It's your idea, Tim," the silver-haired fox said.
"Yeah, but it's your basement," Elf Lord countered.
Gibbs sighed. "Invite them if you wish." Raising his voice slightly to include Tony and Ziva, he said, "Meet in my basement in a half hour."
"Yes, Boss," DiNozzo said.
Smiling, McGee headed to Labby, then Autopsy to brief the other three on what was going to go down.
The entire team was crowded in Gibbs' basement at 8:00 that night, surrounding his latest work-in-progress. McGee carried a small paperback book with him entitled "A" is for Alibi. Once everyone was settled, he asked, "Who wants to read first?"
No one volunteered for a few seconds, but then Abby piped up, "I will." She took the book from McGee's outstretched hand and, opening it up to the first page, began to read.
My name is Kinsey Millhone. I'm a private investigator, licensed by the state of California. I'm thirty-two years old, twice divorced, no kids. The day before yesterday I killed someone and the fact weighs heavily on my mind. I'm a nice person and I have a lot of friends. My apartment is small but I like living in a cramped space. I've lived in trailers most of my life, but lately they've been getting too elaborate for my taste, so now I live in one room, a "bachelorette." I don't have pets. I don't have houseplants. I spend a lot of time on the road and I don't like leaving things behind. Aside from the hazards of my profession, my life has always been ordinary, uneventful, and good. Killing someone feels odd to me and I haven't quite sorted it through. I've already given a statement to the police, which I initialed page by page and then signed. I filled out a similar report for the office files. The language in both documents is neutral, the terminology oblique, and neither says quite enough.
Nikki Fife first came to my office three weeks ago. I occupy one small corner of a large suite of offices that house the California Fidelity Insurance Company, for whom I once worked. Our connection now is rather loose. I do a certain number of investigations for them in exchange for two rooms with a separate entrance and a small balcony overlooking the main street of Santa Teresa. I have an answering service to pick up calls when I'm out and I keep my own books. I don't earn a lot of money but I make ends meet.
I'd been out for most of the morning, only stopping by the office to pick up my camera. Nikki Fife was standing in the corridor outside my office door. I'd never really met her but I'd been present at her trial eight years before when she was convicted of murdering her husband, Laurence, a prominent divorce attorney here in town. Nikki was in her late twenties then, with striking white-blonde hair, dark eyes, and flawless skin. Her lean face had filled out some, probably the result of prison food with its high starch content, but she still had the ethereal look that had made the accusation of murder seem so incongruous at the time. Her hair had grown out now to its natural shade, a brown so pale that it appeared nearly colorless. She was maybe thirty-five, thirty-six, and the years at the California Institute for Women had left no visible lines.
I didn't say anything at first; just opened the door and let her in.
"You know who I am," she said.
"I worked for your husband a couple of times."
She studied me carefully. "Was that the extent of it?"
I knew what she meant. "I was also there in court when you were being tried," I said. "But if you're asking if I was involved with him personally, the answer is no. He wasn't my type. No offense. Would you like coffee?"
She nodded, relaxing almost imperceptibly. I pulled the coffeepot from the bottom of the file cabinet and filled it from the Sparkletts water bottle behind the door. I liked it that she didn't protest the trouble I was going to. I put in a filter paper and ground coffee and plugged in the pot. The gurgling sound was comforting, like the pump in an aquarium.
Nikki sat very still, almost as though her emotional gears had been disengaged. She had no nervous mannerisms, didn't smoke or twist her hair. I sat down in my swivel chair.
"When were you released?"
"A week ago."
"What's freedom feel like?"
She shrugged. "It feels good, I guess, but I can survive the other way too. Better than you'd think."
I took a small carton of half-and-half out of the little refrigerator to my right. I keep clean mugs on top and I turned one over for each of us, filling them when the coffee was done. Nikki took hers with a murmured thanks.
"Maybe you've heard this before," she went on, "but I didn't kill Laurence and I want you to find out who did."
"Typical," Tony muttered. Abby glared at him before continuing:
"Why wait this long? You could have initiated an investigation from prison and maybe saved yourself some time."
She smiled faintly. "I've been claiming I was innocent for years. Who'd believe me? The minute I was indicted, I lost my credibility. I want that back. And I want to know who did me in."
I had thought her eyes were dark but I could see now that they were a metallic gray. Her look was level, flattened-out, as though some interior light were growing dim. She seemed to be a lady without much hope. I had never believed she was guilty myself but I couldn't remember what had made me so sure. She seemed passionless and I couldn't imagine her caring enough about anything to kill.
"You want to fill me in?"
She took a sip of coffee and then set the mug on the edge of my desk.
"I was married to Laurence for four years, a little more than that. He was unfaithful after the first six months. I don't know why it came as such a shock. Actually, that's how I got involved with him . . . when he was with his first wife, being unfaithful to her with me. There's a sort of egotism attached to being a mistress, I suppose. Anyway, I never expected to be in her shoes and I didn't like it much."
"According to the prosecutor, that's why you killed him."
"Look, they needed a conviction. I was it," she said with the first sign of energy. "I've just spent the last eight years with killers of one kind or another and believe me, the motive isn't apathy. You kill people you hate or you kill in rage or you kill to get even, but you don't kill someone you're indifferent to. By the time Laurence died, I didn't give a damn about him. I fell out of love with him the first time I found out about the other women. It took me a while to get it all out of my system . . ."
"And that's what the diary was all about?" I asked.
"Sure I kept track at first. I detailed every infidelity. I listened in on phone calls. I followed him around town. Then he started being more cautious about the whole thing and I started losing interest. I just didn't give a shit."
A flush had crept up to her cheeks and I gave her a moment to compose herself. "I know it looked like I killed him out of jealousy or rage, but I didn't care about that stuff. By the time he died, I just wanted to get on with my own life. I was going back to school, minding my own business. He went his way and I went mine . . ." Her voice trailed off.
"Who do you think killed him?"
"I think a lot of people wanted to. Whether they did or not is another matter. I mean, I could make a couple of educated guesses but I don't have proof of anything. Which is why I'm here."
"Why come to me?"
She flushed again slightly. "I tried the two big agencies in town and they turned me down. I came across your name in Laurence's old Rolodex. I thought there was a certain kind of irony hiring someone he had once hired himself. I did check you out. With Con Dolan down at Homicide."
I frowned. "It was his case, wasn't it?"
Nikki nodded. "Yes it was. He said you had a good memory. I don't like having to explain everything from scratch."
"What about Dolan? Does he think you're innocent?"
"I doubt it, but then again, I did my time so what's it to him?"
I studied her for a moment. She was forthright and what she said made sense. Laurence Fife had been a difficult man. I hadn't been all that fond of him myself. If she was guilty, I couldn't see why she would stir it all up again. Her ordeal was over now and her so-called debt to society had been taken off the books except for whatever remaining parole she had to serve.
"Let me think about it some," I said. "I can get in touch with you later today and let you know."
"I'd appreciate that. I do have money. Whatever it takes."
"I don't want to be paid to rehash old business, Mrs. Fife. Even if we find out who did it, we have to make it stick and that could be tough after all this time. I'd like to check back through the files and see how it looks."
She took a manila folder out of her big leather bag. "I have some newspaper clippings. I can leave those with you if you like. That's the number where I can be reached."
We shook hands. Hers was cool and slight but her grip was strong. "Call me Nikki. Please."
"I'll be in touch," I said.
I had to go take some photographs of a crack in a sidewalk for an insurance claim and I left the office shortly after she did, taking my VW out the freeway. I like my cars cramped and this one was filled with files and law books, a briefcase where I keep my little automatic, cardboard boxes, and a case of motor oil given to me by a client. He'd been cheated by two con artists who had "allowed" him to invest two grand in their oil company. The motor oil was real enough but it wasn't theirs; just some Sears thirty-weight with new labels pasted on. It had taken me a day and a half to track them down. In addition to the junk, I keep a packed overnight case back there, too, for God knows what emergency. I wouldn't work for anyone who wanted me that fast. It just makes me feel secure to have a nightgown, toothbrush, and fresh underwear at hand. I have my little quirks I guess. The VW's a '68, one of those vague beige models with assorted dents. It need a tune-up but I never have time.
I thought about Nikki as I drove. I had tossed the manila folder full of clippings on the passenger seat but I really didn't need to look at them. Laurence Fife had done a lot of divorce work and he had a reputation as a killer in court. He was cold, methodical, and unscrupulous, taking any advantage he could. In California, as in many states, the only grounds for divorce are irreconcilable differences or incurable insanity, which eliminates the trumped-up adultery charges that were the mainstay of divorce attorneys and private eyes in the old days. There is still the question of property settlements and custody—money and children—and Laurence Fife could get his clients anything. Most of them were women. Out of court, he had a reputation as a killer of another kind and the rumor was that he had mended many a broken heart in that difficult period between interlocutory and final decrees.
I had found him shrewd, nearly humorless, but exact; an easy man to work for because his instructions were clear and he paid in advance. A lot of people apparently hated him: men for the price he extracted, women for the betrayal of their trust. He was thirty-nine years old when he died. That Nikki was accused, tried, and convicted was just a piece of bad luck. Except for cases that clearly involve a homicidal maniac, the police like to believe murders are committed by those we know and love, and most of the time they're right—a chilling thought when you sit down to dinner with a family of five. All those potential killers passing their plates.
"She's right about that," Gibbs said. The rest of the team nodded, although Tony had to suppress silent laughter at that last sentence.
Abby continued reading:
As nearly as I could remember, Laurence Fife had been having drinks with his law partner, Charlie Scorsoni, the night of his murder. Nikki was at a meeting of the Junior League. She got home before Laurence, who arrived about midnight. He was taking medication for numerous allergies and before he went to bed, he downed his usual capsule. Within two hours, he was awake—nauseated, vomiting, doubled over with violent stomach cramps. By morning, he was dead. An autopsy and lab test showed that he'd died as a result of infesting oleander, ground to a fine powder and substituted for the medication in the capsule he took: not a masterly plot, but one employed to good effect. Oleander is a common California shrub. There was one in the Fife's backyard as a matter of fact. Nikki's fingerprints were found on the vial along with his. A diary was discovered among her possessions, certain entries detailing the fact that she'd found out about his adulteries and was bitterly angry and hurt, contemplating divorce. The District Attorney established quite nicely that no one divorced Laurence Fife without penalty. He'd been married and divorced once before and though neither attorney had handled his case, his impact was evident. He obtained custody of his children and he managed to come out ahead financially. The state of California is scrupulous in its division of assets, but Laurence Fife had a way of maneuvering monies so that even a fifty-fifty split gave him the lion's share. It looked as if Nikki Fife knew better than to try disentangling herself from him legally and had sought other means.
She had motive. She had access. The grand jury heard the evidence and returned an indictment. Once she got into court, it was simply a question of who could persuade twelve citizens of what. Apparently the D.A. had done his homework. Nikki hired Wilfred Brentnell from Los Angeles: a legal whiz with a reputation as the patron saint of lost causes. In some sense, it was almost like admitting her guilt. The whole trial had a sensational air. Nikki was young. She was pretty. She was born with money. The public was curious and the town was small. It was all too good to miss.
The Gothic forensic scientist set down the book and slid it to McGee. "You next. After all, this was your idea."