PJatO || Nicercy || PJatO || Nicercy || All the Percybilities || Nicercy || PJatO || Nicercy || PJatO

Title: All the Percybilities – Meeting Your Other Self

Fandom: Percy Jackson and the Olympians / Heroes of Olympus; kind of Mark of Athena

Disclaimer: All rights reserved to Rick Riordan for he created the awesomeness that is Nico di Angelo. And everything else related to Percy Jackson and the Olympians / Heroes of Olympus. Aside from the Gods, of course. They are all copyright by the old Greeks. This fanfiction on the other hand is entirely mine. No money is made with this, though reviews are more than welcomed.

Warnings: shounen-ai, meeting with AU-worlds, explicit intercourse, anal, oral, child abuse, dark, character death, gender-bender (in one world), shoujo-ai, hetero

Main Pairing: Nico/Percy

Side Pairings: Jason/Reyna, Frank/Hazel, Piper/Annabeth, Chris/Clarisse, Tyson/Ella, Jake/Will, Malcolm/Katie, Lou/Miranda

Side Pairings of the 2nd World: Frederick/Sally, Sammy/Hazel, Bianca/Calypso, canon!Nico/alternate!Percy, alternate!Nico/canon!Percy, Nico/Jim(Percy)

Percy Jackson Canon Characters; Crew of the Argo II: Perseus Jackson, Nico di Angelo, Hazel Levesque, Jason Grace, Thalia Grace, Katie Gardner, Miranda Gardner, Clarisse la Rue, Frank Zhang, Annabeth Chase, Malcolm Cage, Will Solace, Austin Barton, Kayla Hein, Phoebe Burge, Jake Mason, Leo Valdez, Nyssa Black, Drew Tanaka, Piper McLean, Lacy Hunnigan, Mitchell Logan, Travis Stoll, Connor Stoll, Chris Rodriguez, Lou Ellen, Reyna Anderson, Hylla Anderson, Kinzie Cohen, Octavian Simmons, Rachel Elizabeth Dare, Grover Underwood, Tyson, Ella, Mrs. O'Leary, Blackjack, Arion, Scipio, Tempest, Chaos, Nyx, Erebos, Hemera, Aether

2nd World: Nico di Angelo, Bianca di Angelo, Hazel Levesque, Calypso, Sammy Valdez, Zoe Nightshade, Phoebe Burge, Kinzie Cohen, Richard Jackson, Frederick Chase, Sally Chase, James Chase, Laura Chase, Serenity McMoonlace (OFC), Sedanur Aykan (OFC)

Summary: A primeval power decides to show the crew of the Argo II how their reality could be if only little things would have changed. For example, what if Gaia would have also contacted Nico and Bianca and not only Hazel?

Drifting from one reality to the next, the friends also have to cope with their own feelings. Will this journey teach them an important lesson about themselves?

All the Percybilities

Meeting Your Other Self

Second World Part 7: With Jim, Nico and the Rest in the Church

"Mom. I did a bad thing."

"Oh, Jimmy", sighed a blonde man. "We already know that."

Jimmy had his brows furrowed in worry, biting his lips in guilt as he looked from his mother over to his father. Both were sitting at the kitchen table, Sally with a crestfallen and sad look on her face and Frederick with a desperate and disappointed look on his. He stood strong for a moment longer before collapsing in his mother's lap, tears streaming down his face.

"I'm so sorry! I didn't mean to... I just... all I wanted was for him to notice me, but he didn't and he never will and it wasn't worth what I did for it... I'm so sorry, I didn't mean to harm him, I..."

Sally sighed and cradled him closer to comfort him. She looked over at her husband demandingly, who only sighed and shrugged slightly, rubbing his forehead.

"We are not the ones you need to apologize to", stated Frederick. "They are."

Jimmy froze and turned slowly around to face five very angry looking people. His sister was standing next to her doppelganger, a brunette girl with a red bandana in her hair, a Chinese teddy-bear-guy and... Nico di Angelo. Nico di Angelo stood in his mom's kitchen! He blushed furiously and scrambled off her lap.

"Jimmy, how could you do that?", whispered Laura disappointed. "I trusted you! You're my brother. I thought you would... Zoe will never start believing our rulers are good if even you abuse our trust like that! How can you make me look so bad?! Where is he? Where is Percy Jackson?!"

"Laura, we know it's not your fault", murmured Annabeth, resting one hand on her shoulder.

"No, it's not. It's his fault", growled Nico with a deathly glare. "Out. Everyone who has not kidnapped my Percy will leave this room now. I have a thing or two to say. Now."

James stared wide-eyed at his sister, who just left with the brunette and Annabeth, as well as Jimmy's parents and uncle. He couldn't believe that even his mom would leave him alone now! He shifted uncomfortably and stared up at the hot half-Italian. His blush darkened again. He had never been this close to Nico di Angelo. He felt as if his heart was about to burst with joy. Until his back hit the wall hard, knocking the air out of him. Gasping for air, he stared at the half-blood with the dark and angry eyes, who held him slightly in the air, pressed tightly against the wall. If Nico's one hand wouldn't be around Jimmy's throat, this would be pretty much like one of his dirtier fantasies.

"You are not worth being the son of Sally Jackson", growled Nico with gritted teeth, his voice more than disgusted. "You're nothing like Percy. How can you sell him out like that?!"

"I... I know that I'm nothing like him", gasped Jimmy shamefully, tears prickling in his eyes.

"No you're not", huffed the Ghost Prince angered. "And I will make you pay for every little injury my Percy has once he's returned. If he has a single cut anywhere, I will make you pay."

"I... I didn't take him away so he gets hurt, I swear I don't want him to get hurt!", mumbled James with big, pleading eyes, very much like Percy.

It was hard for Nico to stand strong when faced with that look. Even though those eyes weren't as deep and green as the wild sea, they were still as strong and yet vulnerable and so full of emotions.

"Then tell me why?!", demanded the son of Hades to know. "Why did you take my Percy away?!"

"Why do you love him?!", whispered Jimmy desperately, feeling his tears running down his cheeks. "Why him? Why is he better than me?! Why...?"

Nico frowned at him. And even though he was angry at this boy for taking his Percy away, Jimmy still looked too much like Percy. Too much for Nico to simply watch him cry. Gritting his teeth in irritation, he put the mortal down and tried to breath deep.

"I love him because he is the purest being on this planet", replied the Ghost Prince. "I don't care if others may view that differently, but to me, he is perfection."

"It's... It's not fair...", whispered Jimmy, trying to catch his air again. "Why can't I have you too...? Why does he get both of you?! Why... don't I deserve you...?"

"Both of us?", grunted Nico suspiciously. "What are you talking about? Where is he?"

"He's... He's with Lord di Angelo", replied Jimmy softly and rubbed his eyes.

"Why did you bring him there? And, believe me, if the answer is not good, I will tear you apart."

"Because I love him!", exclaimed James, his eyes wide as he clasped his hands over his mouth.

"You love Percy?", frowned Nico, now completely confused.

"No", huffed James, blushing a furious red. "I love Lord di Angelo!"

"Oh...", nodded the son of Hades slowly.

"Yes", hissed Jimmy ashamed and averted his eyes. "I sold Percy out because I though maybe, just maybe, bringing Lord di Angelo a real, living demi-god would gain me his attention. That he may notice me and maybe even... talk to me... Even just for a moment, a split second would be enough, just once I want to be the center of his attention... But it wasn't enough, it's never enough... All my life I've trained and done everything to be a good soldier, to get praised so he may one day notice me, but now I know that he will never acknowledge my existence... He was so captivated by the demi-god... He... He didn't even acknowledge that I was there... All he did was staring at Percy with those intense, dark eyes... And... And then he even carried him around... Just... Just like that... I... He didn't even look at me... He only had eyes for Percy..."

"Great. So you're in love with Nico. Wonderful, why can't I have my Percy chasing after me with such determined devotion?", huffed the son of Hades with a pout.

"What?", blinked Jimmy confused and rubbed his eyes. "But you do..."

"What?", grunted Nico with a frown.

"He loves you, that's what he said to me. That's why I hoped he wouldn't be angry with me for taking him with me, because I thought maybe he understands, maybe he would be ready to do the same to get you", sighed James and stood up, walking over to stand in front of Nico with wide, pleading eyes. "But... He went with Lord di Angelo willingly. Maybe... he doesn't want you that much after all. At least not you. Maybe... if Percy takes him away from me completely, can... can I have you...? I can be whatever you want, just give me a chance!"

"Don't", growled Nico warningly, catching Jimmy's wrists and pinning him against the wall. "Don't be stupid, boy. I'm not the Nico you love and I never will be. And you're not my Percy."

He pushed himself off the other male and left the kitchen. Jimmy stared after him bewildered, hurt and confused, gliding down the wall, tears running down his cheeks again.


"Okay", growled Nico as he entered the office of the pater. "We need a plan."

"Well, did you question him, or did you just curse him for taking your precious Disney Princess away?", grunted the brunette girl unamused.

"Perhaps more so the latter", huffed the son of Hades with a pout. "Oh, shut up, Clarisse. I want to see you dealing with the guy who kidnapped Chris."

"Chris wouldn't be stupid enough to get himself kidnapped all of the time", snorted Clarisse. "Seriously, what is wrong with that stupid sea brat?"

"Yes, yes, can we get back to the part where Frank is here?", interrupted Annabeth irritated.

The Canadian stood between them, staring doe-eyed from one to the other. "What are you guys doing here would be the better question. How did you find us? And what was that about?"

"Okay, so... Long story short, we met the huntresses, my other self and she contacted her brother, who then kidnapped Percy...", started the daughter of Athena in a rushed voice.

"To get some praising from this world's me, so other-Annabeth brought us here because she knew her brother would return here", ended Nico annoyed. "Now, if you're here, where is my sister?"

"Uh... kind of... gone?", shrugged Frank, fearing Nico's rage. "She needed some air."

"Calm down. All of you", interrupted Sally sternly as the shadows crept closer around Nico. "She needed to be alone to digest everything. Don't worry, she will be fine."

Nico gulped hard. It was impossible to not nod obediently when Sally Jackson gave you that glare.

"Mom, are you sure?", asked Laura with a worried frown from where she was hugging her dad.

"I think I need to lay down... I'm not quite understanding what in the world is going on here", muttered Frederick Chase, staring from Laura to Annabeth and back again. "My head hurts."

"Don't worry, I know that feeling", muttered Richard with a glare. "Come, I will explain everything to you in detail while they deal with the amount of kidnapped half-bloods."

"I would appreciate a tea too", huffed Frederick and followed the pater out.

"When Hazel and I landed in this world, we seeked shelter in this church and met Father Richard and this world's Sally here", explained Frank slowly. "They told us everything about this world and how Sally had been contacted by Chaos who had ordered her to take care of us."

"I have the sight", smiled Sally in explanation. "I think that is why she contacted me. That and the fact that my children were on board of your ship."

Annabeth blushed slightly. She should feel bad for this, but the thought that kind, loving Sally Jackson was her mother made her happy. Her mother was Athena and as far as godly parents went, she wasn't bad. But she wasn't a mother. She was no one to cook you soup when you're sick or comfort you when you're lonely. She had always envied Percy a tiny bit for having such a wonderful mother. And now she was feeling bad for her best friend, remembering how he hadn't seen her in such a long time now...

"Okay. So we got two missing children of the Big Three now. Wonderful", grunted Clarisse annoyed and stood up. "Let me... talk to this world's Sea Princess."


James was still sitting on the kitchen floor, his legs pulled close and his arms wrapped around them. His head hung low in guilt. He shouldn't have done that. He wasn't like that. Never cruel or selfish. But... Was is truly asking to much to be noticed?

"Jack. No, that's not right... John? Whatever your name is – not that I care about it – you are going to tell me in great detail now where you brought our Sea Princess."

He lifted his head to look up at the very angry brunette girl. Just what he needed. Someone else to pick on him. As if he wasn't feeling guilty enough as it was. He averted his eyes again.

"Jim. My name is Jim", whispered the boy softly.

"Okay. Jim then", grunted the girl annoyed. "Clarisse. Or your worst nightmare, depending on what you are going to tell me now, Jimmy-boy."

"I—I... I brought him to Olympus", replied Jimmy and looked up at her desperately. "I promise he won't be harmed. Lord di Angelo isn't like that, really!"

"You put much faith into him", huffed Clarisse skeptically and pulled a chair close to sit in front of the mortal boy, staring down at him critically. "I take it, you love-love-love him. What is wrong with you sea brats? Well, you're not a sea brat, but still."

"I'm sorry", mumbled Jimmy, his eyes big and pleading. "I didn't want to... I wasn't thinking... I just... wanted to impress Lord di Angelo..."

"Congrats, you just won the award for stupidest seaweed brain ever", grunted Clarisse and rolled her eyes. "Now tell me what happened. Exactly. What did Nico say? What did he do? Because, as much as that brat annoys me, I am still going to rip your spine out if something happens to him."

James gulped and nodded obediently before he started to retell everything.


"Well? What did my brother say? You've been in there with him for half an hour now!"

Laura glared skeptically at Clarisse from where she was eating cake with her family, Frank, Nico and Annabeth. Clarisse stared at them in disbelief. They were on a rescue mission and those morons had the nerve to eat cake?! She glared and took Frank's fork to dig into the raspberry cake herself.

"Mh, that's good", mumbled the daughter of Ares impressed, her mouth full.

"I am pretty good at baking, thank you", nodded Frederick with a slight glare. "I hope you left my son unharmed. I understand that he endangered one of your friends, but he is still my only son."

"Naw, he's fine. But I think he's still crying. Damn, that boy is better at feeling guilty than anyone I have ever seen", grunted Clarisse and rolled her eyes, taking Frank's plate away completely to eat the cake herself. "Not being a demi-god is really not good for his self-esteem."

"And what did he say now?", groaned Nico annoyed. "Anything useful?"

"Actually yes", nodded Clarisse and put the cake down. "We should hide. And by we I mean you, me, wise girl and the huntress. Because it seems two guys are going to fetch 'their guest's consort'."

All eyes turned to a very confused Frank. "What are you looking at me like that for?"

"Well, let's see", hummed Clarisse mock-thoughtful. "You managed to lose the gold girl, who oh so happens to look exactly like one of the three emperors around here. You don't think she, maybe, ran into someone who recognized her face? And who else could be her 'consort'?"

"We're going to have a very, very serious conversation about that later on, Zhang", warned Nico with a glare. "But for now... I guess Clarisse is right."

"No, wait. What if we do something... different?", smirked Annabeth and Laura at the same moment, both having a mischievous gleam in their eyes.

"Okay, that is just creepy", declared Clarisse with one raised eyebrow.

"Why? You want your Percy back, preferably without starting a war with the gods."

"And Jimmy wants to be with this world's Nico. It's perfect."

"What? I don't understand a word", huffed Frank confused.

"Simple!", grinned Annabeth delighted while her doppelganger turned to her family. "We will let them collect Frank while we hide and once Frank is with Hazel and knows she's alright, he will let her give Nico a signal. I know you underworld brats have a connection."

"Mom, do you still have that hair dye from when uncle Rich wanted to cover his gray streaks?"

"Sure, love. Why?", asked Sally confused.

"Great! Go and get it! And the green contact-lenses you had bought for dad as a joke for Halloween. And one of Jimmy's old jeans!", ordered Laura with a grin.

"And then, when Nico knows they're safe and preferably alone so the gods don't notice their missing right away, he will shadow-travel up to Olympus and exchange our Percy for Jimmy. Jimmy certainly won't have anything against distracting this world's Nico until we're out of reach – or better yet, out of this world", concluded Annabeth pleased with her plan.

"That is... ridiculous", grunted Nico and shook his head.


Jimmy yelped surprised as something suddenly hit his face and covered his sight.

"Get into the bathroom, your sister is waiting there to dye your hair. And then you'll change into those clothes and do just exactly as we tell you."

The mortal frowned confused and pulled the orange shirt from his face. Just to blush the most furious red possible. Nico di Angelo was half-naked in front of him. And he was, obviously, holding Nico's shirt. Yes, it had that earthy, musky scent that made Jimmy's heart flutter ever since he had once caught a whiff of it years ago when the lord had visited the academy to look at the newbies.

"W... What...?", blinked Jimmy doe-eyed.

"Your sister will dye your hair black. She also organized a set of green contacts for you. I don't think contacts could fool anyone who has ever looked into those stunning eyes, but you'll just have to distract him enough to not look to closely into your eyes", grunted Nico.

The way those muscles flexed when he was gesturing made Jimmy's stomach tingle. "What...?"

"You told Clarisse someone is on the way to collect Frank. Well, we will use that opportunity to smuggle you into Olympus and exchange you for our Percy", declared the son of Hades.

"W... What am I supposed to do?", yelped the mortal and blushed furiously as Nico came closer.

Their noses were practically touching and those dark, dark eyes looked so angry and determined that he would not even have disobeyed if Nico would have ordered him to go outside and dance in a ballet dress in front of his men. He may not be a god, but he still had the same powerful authority.

"You're going to dress up like Percy and then I will bring you to my doppelganger's bedchamber and take my Percy with me, as well as my sister and Frank", growled Nico. "While you will be a good boy and stay there. After you have brought us that mess, it is the least you can do."

"But... What... What am I supposed to do there?", blinked Jimmy confused.

"You will distract the other me so I get enough time to bring my family back to our ship. I would appreciate it if you could distract him long enough so we can leave this world behind."

James frowned. First at the handsome, still half-naked guy in front of him and then at the shirt. His mind tried to process what this Nico had said. But it was hard to concentrate when those angry eyes and those hard muscles were distracting him.

"How am I supposed to do that? We're talking about Lord di Angelo here!"

"You said he took Percy with him to his bedchamber", grunted Nico displeased. "It's not all that hard to figure out what my other self has planned to do. You will take over."

"W... What?", yelped Jimmy with the widest eyes possible.

The dark eyes hardened some more as they bore into his and Nico was backing him against the wall once more. Jimmy gulped and desperately tried to play his blush down. But it wasn't helping him any that the half-Italian was smirking at him and leaning in some more, so close that James could even feel the cold breath of the other ghosting over his neck, making him shudder.

"You will distract the other Nico, the best way I could possibly picture", whispered Nico in a low, nearly seductive voice. "You will get naked and you will spread your legs as far apart as humanly possible and then you will beg like a whore, as if someone is paying you for it. Am I clear?"

"N... Naked...? B... Beg...?", gasped James beet red.

"Yes", growled the son of Hades. "You will play the part of Percy, just that you're going to beg him to fuck you. You will beg him so convincing that he won't be able to deny you. I'm sure you'll do good, your sister told us just how long you've been pining for him. I'm sure you'll be very convincing in your desperate begging. You'll tell him you changed your mind, that you want to be with him, that he's a god and so much more than a mere demi-god."

"Changed my mind...?", repeated Jimmy slowly.

"Yes. Because my Percy won't give in to his advances", grunted Nico annoyed. "But you will. You will let him fuck you, long and hard. Long enough for us to leave unnoticed."

"B... But he will never want to take me!", whined Jimmy and shook his head.

"That's why we're going to dress you up as Percy, idiot", groaned the Ghost Prince and rolled his eyes. "That way, he won't be able to resist you. Just beg like there's no, like it's the one thing you want most on this entire planet. Which it is, as far as I'm informed. Beg. Like. A. Whore."

Jimmy was still staring wide-eyed as he was being pushed over to the bathroom. This was horrible! ...Was it bad that he was aroused like never before by this idea...?