A/N I own nothing! What if Rachel was in Quinn's position in season 1, she was dating Finn but cheated with Puck and got pregnant? Here is my take on what would happen. One shot at the moment, up to you guys if I continue. The only thing that's different is that Rachel does love Noah but she feels like he is only a player that is why she isn't with him.

Walking to her boyfriend's locker in a complete daze, Rachel ignored everyone just focusing on where she needed to be; she needed to tell her boyfriend that she was pregnant. The catch? It wasn't his baby, they hadn't even had sex but luckily she had researched some things and she believed she had found a story that her simple minded boyfriend would buy.

"Have I done something wrong Rach? You have been ignoring me and are you okay?" Finn asked concerned.

"I'm pregnant."

Seeing the shock in his eyes, Rachel started babbling about how she found out and started crying.

"Mine?" Was all Finn managed out.

"Yes." Rachel sobbed.

"B-but we haven't even had sex." Finn asked confused.

"That night in the hot tub. My doctor said that a hot tub's water temperature is perfect condition for sperm to reach the goal." Rachel breathed out in a hurry praying that he brought the story.

Nodding, Finn hugged his girlfriend.

"It will be okay I'm here for you." Finn whispered comforting his love.

Rachel just sobbed into his arms until the bell rang signalling that they had class.

Xxxxx

"Dude why have you been all PMS lately." Puck asked his best friend after Math class.

"Nothing don't worry about it." Finn snapped as he continued to walk down the hallway.

"Finn." Puck asked slightly worried.

"Rachel's pregnant." Finn whispered before leaving Puck with his thoughts.

Puck was gunna be a dad.

Xxxxx

"Sup MILF." Puck smirked at a scared Rachel.

"Shut up." Rachel begged.

"So whose the daddy? I think it's pretty weird considering you said you were a virgin when we did it?" Puck asked staring at her flat belly.

"Finn's." Rachel offered.

"Bullshit Rachel," Puck snapped before dragging her into a classroom.

"I can take care of you and the baby. I'm not my dad." Puck said seriously.

He wouldn't really admit it but he loved Rachel Berry, ever since he was about 11, but then she hooked up with Finn and she became off limits, but Puck was never good at playing by the rules.

"Why would you? You'll just cheat on me and break mine and the baby's heart." Rachel said trying not to cry.

Moving closer to Rachel, Puck cupped her face,

"I won't you know. I promise." Puck told her.

Looking into Puck's eyes, Rachel saw the truth but she didn't want to get hurt, she loved Puck but she didn't want to trap him into loving her too so she said something that was completely untrue.

"I only slept with you because I thought Finn and head cheerleader Quinn were doing it... plus I felt like a loser that day." Rachel snapped before storming out of the classroom.

Xxxxx

Rachel was the lead of the glee club but somehow managed to have the quarter back of the football team as her boyfriend, so seeing Finn flirting with Quinn broke her heart and reminded her of her social status; a loser... so when Puck told her how beautiful and sexy she was; how lucky Finn was to have her as a girlfriend, she kissed him and it led to her losing her virginity. It was magical; he was gentle and soft and Rachel felt loved and cared for, but she is angry that she didn't insist on more protection other then the words... trust me.

"Rachel? Rachel?" Mr Shue repeated until Rachel's head snapped up giving the teacher her attention.

"I'm sorry my head's been all over the place." Rachel mumbled, before looking towards the door to see the unholy trinity there.

"We have three new members, Quinn, Santana and Brittany." Mr Shue smiled.

"Welcome girls!" Finn smiled at the cheerleaders who each gave him a flirty look before taking their seats towards the back of the room.

"Rachel you had a song you'd like to perform for us?" Mr Shue smiled.

"Um, no; not any more." Rachel said quickly seeing the look the cheerio's gave her when told they'd have to listen to her sing.

"Oh are you sure?" Mr Shue asked shocked.

"Yes." Rachel whispered, "Excuse me." Rachel mumbled before rushing out of the room and straight to the bathroom to empty her stomach.

Xxxxx

The next day she found some ginger ale and crackers in her locker... she knew they were from Noah.

Xxxxx

A few days passed and during glee club Mr Shue announced that they had more members.

"Having the cheerleaders in the group must have cause some more football players to join." He told the group happily as Mike, Matt and Puck walked in the choir room.

"Audition." Rachel blurted out receiving eye rolls. "They have to audition."

"Mike and Matt already did." Mr Shue told Rachel, "But to be fair, Noah you'll have to as well."

"Fine, she knows who this is for." Puck smirked before nodding to the band.

[Chorus]
It's gonna take a lot to drag me away from you
There's nothing that a hundred men, or more, could ever do
Just like the rain, down in Africa
It's gonna take some time but I know you're worth fighting for -
I'd fight for you

Hey ba bum ba eh ba bum ba eh eh ba bum ba eh
I'd fight for you
Hey ba bum ba eh ba bum ba eh eh ba bum ba eh
I'd fight for you

[Verse 1]
Friends are cool but we both know - they don't wanna see us together
Don't wanna lose what I live for - I'm willing to do whatever
'cause I don't wanna see you cry
Give our love another try
I bet we get it right this time
As long as you're prepared to fight

[Bridge]
I don't wanna live another day without your body next to me
I'm not gonna let them break us down
'cause baby I know now

[Chorus]
It's gonna take a lot to drag me away from you
I'd fight for you
There's nothing that a hundred men, or more, could ever do
I'd fight for you
Just like the rain, down in Africa
I'd fight for you
It's gonna take some time but I know you're worth fighting for -

[Verse 2]
Lesgo
What they say - It don't even matter
They don't really understand
Without each other, we are barely breathing
Let's get air in these hearts a gain
'cause I don't wanna see you cry - give our love another try
I bet we get it right this time
As long as you're prepared to fight
Prepared to fight

[Bridge]
I don't wanna live another day without your body next to me
I'm not gonna let them break us down
'cause baby I know now (know now, know now)

[Chorus]
It's gonna take a lot to drag me away from you
I'd fight for you
There's nothing that a hundred men, or more, could ever do
I'd fight for you
Just like the rain, down in Africa
I'd fight for you
It's gonna take some time but I know you're worth fighting for -
I'd fight for you

Hey ba bum ba eh ba bum ba eh eh ba bum ba eh
I'd fight for you
Hey ba bum ba eh ba bum ba eh eh ba bum ba eh

If you've got someone that's worth fighting for
Don't let nobody hold you down let me hear you say
WOOOOOOAHHHHHH
If you've found someone that's worth dying for
The one you can't live without let me hear you say
WOOOOOOAHHHHHH

[Chorus]
It's gonna take a lot to drag me away from you
There's nothing that a hundred men, or more, could ever do
I'd fight for you
Just like the rain, down in Africa
I'd fight for you
It's gonna take some time but I know you're worth fighting forrrrrrrr
WOAH

It's gonna take a lot to drag me away from you
I'd fight for you
There's nothing that a hundred men, or more, could ever do
I'd fight for you
Just like the rain, down in Africa
I'd fight for you
It's gonna take some time but I know you're worth fighting for

"Aw Puck." Quinn smiled brightly.

"W-When did you two get together?" Finn asked annoyed which he had no right to be.

"A week ago, we wanted to keep it secret for a bit" Quinn said in her bitchy tone.

"Quinn we spoke about this..." Puck began, yes they had bumped uglies but they weren't dating, they were both in love with other people, plus Puck was expecting a baby with the said girl he loved.

"Shh Noah, wouldn't want me to tell secrets?" Quinn whispered in his ear,

How the fuck did Quinn know, he should of guessed she knows fucking everything. Not wanting Rachel to get hurt even more and thinking that Rachel didn't love him, Puck claimed Quinn's mouth in a searing kiss, breaking Rachel's heart.

"Congrats." Rachel said tightly before excusing herself to go vomit and cry. Why did everyone love Quinn fucking Fabray?

A/N Continue?