PJatO || Stonicercy || PJatO || Four Can Play That Game || PJatO || Stonicercy || PJatO

Title: Four Can Play That Game – Revenge of the Princes

Fandom: Percy Jackson and the Olympians / Heroes of Olympus; somewhere post both series

PJatO Disclaimer: All rights reserved to Rick Riordan for he created the awesomeness that is Nico di Angelo. And everything else related to Percy Jackson and the Olympians / Heroes of Olympus. Aside from the Gods, of course. They are all copyright by the old Greeks. This fanfiction on the other hand is entirely mine. No money is made with this, though reviews are more than welcomed.

Warnings: shounen-ai, established relationships, foursome, explicit intercourse, anal, bondage, doubling, D/s (three doms), orgasm-denial, voyeurism (somewhat), cheating (kind of)

Main Pairing: Stolls/nico/Percy

Side Pairings: Travis/Percy, Connor/Nico

Percy Jackson Characters: Perseus Jackson, Nico di Angelo, Travis Stoll, Connor Stoll

Summary: Connor and Nico, as well as Travis and Percy, had been a couple for months now. And the Stoll brothers had been switching places frequently to enjoy their brother's lover. What they didn't know, however, is that their lovers know about their little game. And decide to play one of their own to tease their boyfriends.

As requested by I'mColdInTheSun! Okay, that one was a load of work to get it working... I hope the outcome pleases you. ;)

Four Can Play That Game

Revenge of the Princes

Travis Stoll grinned eagerly.

He and his brother had been dating the biggest Greek heroes in existence for four months now. While he had Percy Jackson on his hook, his brother had Nico di Angelo wrapped around his little finger. It had been a big surprise for both sons of Hermes to discover that the greatest heroes were crushing on them, of all people. And the older Stoll was more than glad to take the son of Poseidon. While Connor was pretty eager to claim the son of Hades. And at first, they had been content and overly happy to have their respective boyfriend. But they were brothers, they bragged. Travis loved telling his brother all about the eager begging of his Sea Prince and the wonderfully tight hole. Connor loved telling his brother about the stubborn and strong nature of his Ghost Prince. Until, one day, Connor got overly curious about the submissive nature of his brother's lover while Travis wanted to taste the stubbornness of his brother's lover. They were so different. One eager to submit, the other fighting to the last stand before submitting.

So they decided to switch lovers.

At first they had been reluctant about it and only switched places for a date, but when their lovers didn't make any comment about it, they became bolder and kissed. Then making out. And in the end, claiming their brother's boyfriend. They had sworn that it would be a one-time-thing. But both Stolls found that they were just too much alike. They liked the same. They both enjoyed Percy just as much as they enjoyed Nico. So they often switched. One day, Travis would spend with Percy, the other he would spend with Nico. It was just too hard to decide between the two heroes.

"Sh, stay silent now", ordered Percy in a low purr.

Travis shuddered a that. His boyfriend had blindfolded him and told him that he had a 'special surprise' for him. He bit his lips as he was led into a room. It was dark outside already, everyone was fast asleep. Percy was most likely guiding him to Cabin Three. Perhaps he had bought some new toys he wanted to show to his boyfriend? Travis loved playing with the toys and with his boyfriend, Percy's hole was so sensitive that teasing him alone was sometimes enough to make the son of Poseidon come. The son of Hermes was guided to the bed and sat down. His boyfriend captured his hands and guided them over his head, clicking handcuffs around his wrists. Percy tying him up? That was new. Normally, it was the other way around. If anything, Nico liked tying them up and then riding them. The Ghost Prince was slow to submit, and even then he still fought to have the upper hand. But well, there was a first time for everything, he guessed. It was Valentine's Day, after all. His thoughts were interrupted when his blindfold was pulled from his eyes and he gaped.

"Connor?" - "Travis?"

The brothers stared at each other, both tied to the head-board of Nico's bed. Travis turned to ask Percy what was going on, just to find the son of Poseidon sitting on the foot-end of the bed. Next to the son of Hades. The older Stoll turned back to his brother.

"What are you doing here?", hissed Travis.

"Nico blindfolded me and said he had a surprise. I thought he would bring me to his cabin for a hot night of fucking! What are you doing here?"

"Basically the same... Just with Percy", grunted Travis and frowned.

Connor turned to glare at their boyfriends. "What's going on here?"

"Basically, you two being cheating, arrogant, condescending assholes", replied Nico angered.

"Did you two really think we are unable to tell our boyfriend apart from his brother?", whispered Percy disbelieving and shook his head. "We've known about your little game from the beginning."

"But you never said something", said Connor irritated.

"So what?", snorted the Ghost Prince, pulling the shadows closer to him. "That gives you the right to trick us and cheat on us? Because we're just nice fucks to you."

"No! No, I didn't mean it like that!", gasped Connor wide-eyed. "That's not it!"

"He just meant that... Why are you only confronting us now?", whispered Travis.

""Because I thought that it was just Connor also doing me, while Nico thought it was just Travis also doing him. We didn't know that you switched and that both of you were fucking both of us. But then last week we came to that conclusion together", replied Percy softly. "So why?"

"Because you're both irresistible", answered Travis with a heavy sigh. "I love you, Percy. And I've been the happiest camper when you asked me to go out with you. And the same goes for Connor. He loves Nico and was just equally happy. But... we both got curious and... it was supposed to be a one-time thing. But you two, you have no idea how irresistible you are. You're so different. I can't and don't want to decide between you. Neither does Connor. Right, brother?"

"Completely", nodded the younger Stoll hastily. "You're awesome. You're so cute and beautiful and soft, Perce. And you're so gorgeous and rough and edgy, Nikki. And I want you both."

Nico and Percy exchanged a short look before the son of Poseidon leaned in between the brothers.

"That still doesn't give you the right to deceive us like that", whispered the Sea Prince. "You lied to us and used us for your please instead of being honest to us. That means you don't trust us."

"We do!", objected Connor. "Of course we trust you! But we were afraid that you... that we would loose both of you if we told you that we wanted you..."

Percy smiled softly at him and leaned in to kiss him. The younger Stoll was slightly surprised at that and the older glared from the side. But then their Sea Prince turned and also kissed Travis.

"Jackson", growled Nico irritated. "I told you no kissing-and-making-up."


This is the part where you have to go to my profile on AO3 to read the rest of the story because apparently some people seriously just solemnly go around FFNet with the goal of finding stuff to report. I never new Randall from "Recess" really existed and assumed this to be some kind of FFNet boogeyman, to be honest. Apparently, those "Critics" United really exist. Consider me surprised.

Here's the link to the story on AO3 (you just need to remove the -):


~*~ The End ~*~