If I rate your story, I use this scale:
10 is a perfect, model fanfic that all fanfics should aspire to, truly awesome
9 is excellent, exceptional in nearly all ways, what I aim for, impressive
8 is very good, with a bit of room for improvement evident, nice
7 is good, with clear room for improvement and non-major errors or problems
6 is pretty good, with distracting errors or some real problems with plot, dialog, format, or narration
5 is passable, with frequent errors or serious problems that really should have been addressed before posting

Most fairly good fics on FFnet are about a 7, some lower or higher. Only about 2 percent of fics are a 9 or higher. I can go for months not seeing a 10. A 6 is what happens if a 17 year old proofs a draft of a fairly good story once and posts without really reworking it. A 4 or 5 is normally written by someone under 14, or very lazy.

My writing is about 7.5 to 8, suffering mostly from a few minor errors and a lack of plot or originality. Most good published novels are 8 to 8.5 (most books are more like 6 or 7). A bit of proofing and added narration can easily boost a good story from mangled 6 to a polished 7.5.

Story status:

FY - Tsukareta - not actually dead, I'm working on this bit by bit

Teen Titans - A different Betrothed : likely 7 or so chapters
Ch 1 posted
Ch 2 - more about Raven, Roommates- at 97 pct. (polishing)
Ch 3 - Lazarus -at 90 pct. (editing, adding a bit, polishing)
Ch 4 5 - the actual damn romance - at 40 pct. (adding fluff as I go)

Danny Phantom - Danny/Ember story: 7 chapters minimum
Ch 1 -Two girls plot- at 90 pct. (a bit more work, polishing)
Ch 2 - Happy birthday - at 70 pct. (more content)
Ch 3 - Dinner with a Ghost and Chipping Away - at 60 pct. (fluffing)
Ch 4 - Secrets - at 50 pct. (more content)
Ch 5 -Hard to keep- at 25 pct. (very rough currently, writing Sam's outrage)
Ch 6 and on - 15 pct.(rough ideas, here the darkness starts)

Naruto - NaruTema story (Naru-Ino friendship)
In progress, 59 pages written

Detective Academy Q - Kyu/Yukihira Sakurako (6 or more chapters)
1 - done
2 - 90 pct done
3 - 60 pct done
4 - 30 pct done

Star Trek: Voyager - Paris/Seven
just started this one

Buffy fic, with a bit of Hellsing - Spike/Willow, refers to Alucard/Seras
just started

Gundam Wing - Heero/Hilde fic at about 55 pct.

WITCH - Promise -: Phobos/Will and Caleb/Elyon, 3 to 6 chapters
Ch 1 at 75 pct.
Ch 2 at 25 pct.

Kim Possible - Himitsu - Ron/Shego at least 2 chapters: (refers to Ron w/ Bonnie, Tara, Yori, etc)
damaged, being rewritten even better

Inuyasha - Sesshoumaru/Kagome story at least 3 chapters:
damaged, being rewritten even better, I love this little fic

My favorite animes/mangas are TOKKO, Detective Conan (Case Closed), Detective Academy Q, Inukami, Hellsing, Bleach, Evangelion, Rebirth, Psychic Academy, Hagane Renkinjitsushi (FMA), Naruto, Furikuri (FLCL), Gundam Wing, Teen Titans, or any with quiet, obsessive, violent or evil boys figuring prominently in their plot. I like characters I can identify with. =) And redheaded girls with cat ears and tails, can't go wrong with those.

Some of my favorite quotes from fanfics:

"They say that blood is thicker than any steel. In our case it is a chain that manacles us together in an everlasting web spiraling down into nothingness."
-Kanna in a fanfic, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/1825663/27/

"Your questioning of the obvious exceeds my expectations.”
-Sesshoumaru in a fanfic, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/1767639/3/

"Are you finished being dramatic now sir? Your 'Cup O'Noodles' is getting cold."
Ryoga just sighed. "I guess so."
-Ryoga and his liquid fighter, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/227422/3/

"I am not a jerk," he said eying Isane disdainfully. "Neither am I psychopathic. If anything I am a highly aggressive, deviously smart, homicidal sociopath with very little hold on my inhibitions."
-Kurotsuchi Mayuri, Bleach fic, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/5290023/29/Quantum_Mechanics

Spike glared at him, and then glanced back to Xander and Faith. “I’m not insane,” he said. “Not really. I’ve been insane. This isn’t at all like it.”
-Spike/Faith BTVS fic, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2047783/1/

“Yeah….and if olive oil comes from olives, then where does baby oil come from?” Bloo mused out loud.
-Bloo in a Foster's fanfic, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2754773/1/

“ahahahahaack…Damn evil cackling irritating my throat.” Orochimaru said as he entered into a coughing fit courtesy of his evil cackling.
- best Orochimaru quote ever, in a Naruto fic, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2842610/14/

"You may have deflected my attacks by turning into a human top. Try deflecting this. Shizen Kuchiyose no Jutsu – WHAT THE &?"
A loud roar echoed through the stadium, air displaced as something huge entered the area. Looking up, Neji froze. It was understandable, considering how many forty-foot tall, bone-white ferrets had been seen in the Leaf before – absolutely none.
-- Naruto summons a giant ferret demon, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/1351778/17/

“Take your time. I want to create the appearance that I’m soft, feminine and lovable. And if you don’t pull that off, I’ll dark blast you until next week.” Raven threatened.
- Rob x Rav fanfic, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2027645/1/

Raven nodded lightly and looked down. "And I'm sorry for trying to club you like a baby seal."
- http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2047745/4/

Tatsuki looked back and forth throughout Ichigo and Rukia's discussion. Listened to their conversation. Her mind thought back to Rukia's reluctance in parting from Ichigo. Her demanding talk. Ichigo reluctantly obeying her commands and her frazzled mind made a rather rash conclusion, she would later realize.
"Oh dear god no...", she deadpanned. "My boyfriend's become a Pokemon..." She chucked softly.
Tatsuki, in a Bleach fic http://www.fanfiction.net/s/4147806/4/

It was one thing to be the probing intellect doing the analyzing. It was another altogether to have some wind-tossed, dewey-eyed little optimist regarding him with enough compassion and understanding to make him want to throttle her.
-Kagome and Sess fanfic Laying among Dokatsu, http:///fanficread.php?fid=228&cid=1

“Sorry, if I underestimated the vastness of your stupidity,” Kagura said.
-Iunyasha fanfic, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/1901240/17/

"Or he could just be being paranoid...oh but what fun it would be to send them a dead whore..."
- I love random quotes, Dilandau x OC, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2272698/3/

"I have made a conclusion that I am the only sane person here."
-Vegeta, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/1543564/1/

"Chi-chi, if you put aside the fact that Vegeta tried to kill Goku and Gohan, and blow up the world, what do you think of him as a person?"
- Bulma, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/292788/8/

“I’m getting my laundry done by Robin of the Teen Titans,” Jinx said, “At this point, I’m figuring I’m in a fever dream.”
-Robin/Jinx, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2156765/1/

“Oh look, monsters!” called out Hay-Lin pointing towards the ground. “Look how many there are—and they’re all waving their swords at us! That’s such a cool greeting. Wave back.”
-Haylin is a bit of an airhead, WITCH fanfic, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/3051332/2/

"Ranma want try the ramen?" the girl asked hopefully.
"Ain't nothing going to happen is it?" he asked irritably. "No hypnotic mushrooms, or love potions or nothing like that?"
Ryoko, who had been about to start eating, blinked and looked at her bowl cautiously.
"That's a perfect beginning to the day," Ryoko sighed.
-Ranma/Ryouko fanfic, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/220967/6/

"You must be under the misunderstanding that I care. Let me fix that immediately: I don't. "
-Sesshoumaru x Kagome fanfic, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/638913/23/

"Forgive InuYasha, Kagome, he doesn't mean to be such a clod. He is just insecure right now. Once he gains the full use of Tetsusaiga he will feel better. Then he will have to come up with new excuses for being a clod."
-Miroku in a fanfic, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/1915840/1/

“No, your brother’s just an asshole,” Chichi said with a roll of her eyes. “Vegeta’s a sly, shrewd asshole with a certain degree of intelligence which actually makes him more of a bastard than an asshole.”
-Chichi, on Vegeta, in a DBZ fanfic, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2216546/6/

Anyway the point is I’m not prepared to live with the guilt knowing that if I hadn’t let you out of my front door, you wouldn’t be lying face down in a gutter with a stab wound in your abdomen.”
“That’s a very specific mental image you have there,” Vegeta joked, causing Bulma to look at him and notice his smirk. “You haven’t been planning anything have you?”
-Bulma and Vegeta, the same fic, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2216546/7/

"Well they're obviously deranged to start a shoot out in broad daylight!" Ayame said under her breath.
"Did you just call this a shoot out?" Kouga demanded. "Do you see me holding a gun?"
-Kouga demonstrating the importance of semantics, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/1921295/6/

"If you touch me, I will fuckin blow you to pieces with star bolts." Starfire said, rather angrily.
-who knew Star had a temper? http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2004372/3/

An extension of Raven’s auric powers wrapped around him and squeezed, he was out of his pelt in a heartbeat crying for help.
“Squeeze ‘em Rae!” Robin yelled from his half nelson. “Squeeze ‘em like a piece of bubble wrap!”
-don't get those two angry, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2374827/6/

“Hey! Shut it, boss. What all we’re doing is passing into Swednborgian’s Space then through the deeper Umbra, find our way to the Gate of Anubis and defeat the immortal guard there and get the key, pass over the River of Blood and through the Seven Circles of Hell, solve the Riddle of the Elements, pass through the Gate of Lost Souls, over the edge of the world and then into Tartarus. We do the same on the way back. It’ll be a walk in the park. I’ll bring snacks." “No.” Robin stated solidly. “We aren’t going to let you any of you throw your lives away.”
“Except you.” Raven said to Bats. “I really don’t like you that much. You can come.”
-same fic, Raven just doesn't like Batman, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2374827/13/

Twenty-four hours ago, Tsukune was worried that his life for the last ten years was the product of a cruel prank played by an indifferent Universe. Since his arrival at Youkai Academy, his worry evaporated with the certainty that the Universe was not apathetic to his plight. He knew now, with a conviction that bordered on religious fervor, that the Universe hated him with a fury that dwarfed the death throes of red giant in final collapse.
Tsukune's thoughts in a Rosario Vampire fic, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/5572443/5/

Chip gave his little bud a weak smile, “Maybe. They do say that love isn’t for the faint of heart. Maybe all I’ve gotta do is keep trying? Yeah,” he seemed struck by a sudden surge of confidence, “I’ll wear her down! Chip Skylark will get the girl!”
He jumped when he heard the sound of police sirens blaring about a block away, “Uh, but first...Chip Skylark will flee the area!”
-Chip is after Vicky in a Fairly Oddparents fic, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2203297/6/

"Now you listen to me..."She began, her voice going dangerously low, reminding him of a once homicidal Gaara. "I have been chained to a guy that has half the continent after his head. I have just fought off two missing nins, pretended to be kidnapped, walked away from my home, walked through this godforsaken desert, dealt with an extremely creepy Kazekage and I am now three inches away from killing you in the most painful way you can imagine. So you have about three seconds to step aside or I will make you." She snarled as an added effect.
-Hana is scary in a Naruto fic, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/3143592/24/

“Naruto, don't! This guy is way out of our-” What the hell am I saying?! This guy could get rid of that idiot for me! Even I fail the exam it's a small price to pay! “Do your best!”
-Sasuke being evil and trying to Naruto killed, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/3816719/4/

“Look Sasuke,” he said, pointing with his thumb, “It's Akamaru and his pet, Kiba.”
-Akamaru is in fact the dog, from a Naruto fic, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/3303185/7/

"Kiba..." Shino's shades sparkled in the light of one of the spotlights, "This team's ladiesman, is me."
-Shino in a Naruto fic, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2725454/13/

"Look! A distraction!"
-I forget where that came from. Maybe a Kim Possible or Naruto fic.

"Oh, of course." Will rolled her eyes. "I've got a magical amulet hidden under my shirt that has the power to close portals between two different worlds, and my four best friends and I are magical super-heroes. I'm one hard-core skeptic."
-Will in a WITCH fanfic, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2493666/2/

Scowling, his secretary stalked toward Ed's prone form, now nearly buried under the debris of a once whole desk.
"Sir, wouldn't it be wise to call for a medic?"
A raised eyebrow and smirk tossed in her direction, he responded, "Why? I think my desk is far beyond the help of any medic."
-Roy just doesn't care, does he? FMA fanfic, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2475383/1/

“Never mind,” said Shinji, as he reached back into his backpack, pulling out a small key ring. “Looks like a Beta-7 series,” he muttered, as he went through a ring full of similar keys.
“Get handcuffed often?”
Shinji glared at her. “Did anyone here even look into my past before they dragged me here?”
-Shinji in a hilarious Eva fic you HAVE to read, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2695150/10/

“I hate the way you dress, the way you eat, the way sigh in your put upon manner like the world isn’t good enough for you.” Nabiki screamed, advancing with each proclamation. “I hate the way you cry over things like Kuno and the horde, and yet go back for more from them. I hate the way you place yourself on a pedestal you don’t deserve to be on. And I especially hate the way you act put upon by my attempts to strike a legitimate friendship with the man I may have to marry someday.” “I hate you, and everything you stand for. I hate you for every simple minded thought that’s dancing through that empty head of yours.” Nabiki hollered, shoving Akane back against the door. “I hate you for your unbearable attention whoring, your condescending attitude and that stupid ‘pervert’ bullshit!”
-Nabiki dumping on Akane what she deserves, http://www.fanfiction.net/s/1620237/18/

Other quotes:

"It is my fondest desire to bust a host of caps into multitudes of personages."
-Wooden Soldier, Fables TBP vol 4

They say, 'Before you criticise someone, walk a mile in their shoes.
That way, when you criticise them you're a mile away,
and you have their shoes'

Purple: "You've been assigned to the planet Blorch, home of the slaughtering rat-people."
Red: "However, because of your increased height, we have decided to give you the planet Vort, home of the universe's most comfortable couch."

Purple: "Besides, no invader has ever been so -very small. You're very small Zim... You're a tiny thing." Red: "You will be sent toa planet so mysterious, no one has even heard of it."
Purple: "Right. And those who have heard of it dare not speak its name."
Zim: "What's its name?"
Purple: "Oh, I dare not speak it."

Zim: "Umm, is it supposed to be stupid?"
Purple: "It's not stupid. It's advaaaaanced."
-All from the first episode of Invader Zim, The Nightmare Begins"

"Sorry about imprisoning you and turning you into a media freak, honey. It was in the name of science and -- hey, where's your brother?"
"He's in a pig world netherworld cleaning out toilets with his head."
-Dr. Membrane and Gaz, Invader Zim Episode "Gaz, Taster of Pork"

"What you need to do is give the Game Slave to me, or I will plunge you into a nightmare world from which there is no waking."
-Gaz, in Invader Zim episode "Game Slave 2"

"Why is always monkeys? Why can't I be attacked by crazed supermodels?"
-Ron, Kim Possible episode "Exchange"

"When nothing makes sense, I'll fight believing only in myself."
- Hiiro Yuy, in Gundam Wing

"Not every one that saith unto me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into the kingdom of heaven; but he that doeth the will of my Father which is in heaven."
- Matthew 7:21, KJV

Out of the window,
I saw how the planets gathered
Like the leaves themselves
Turning in the wind.
I saw how the night came,
Came striding like the color of the heavy hemlocks
I felt afraid.
And I remembered the cry of the peacocks.
-from the poem Domination of Black by Wallace Stevens

"No bastard ever won a war by dying for his country.
He won it by making the other poor dumb bastard die for his country."
- attributed to General George Patton, Jr.

Will: You want me to find this?
Jack: No. You want you to find this. Because the finding of this finds you incapacitorially finding and/or locating in your discovering, a detecting of a way to save your dolly belle ol' wha's-her-face. (pause) Savvy?
-Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest

Lord Beckett: Loyalty is no longer the currency of the realm. I'm afraid currency is the currency of the realm.

Jack Sparrow: I'm a dishonest man. And a dishonest man, you can always trust to be dishonest. Honestly. But it's those honest ones you need to look out for.

Jack Sparrow: You cannot let him near the chest, man, trust me on this. You can mistrust me less than you can mistrust him. Trust me.
-all from Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest

"Charlie: Nice shooting.
Riley: Good shooting, Charlie. No such thing as nice shooting."
-from the film Land of the Dead

(guns fire in the distance)
What the Hell's that?
Man relax, it's just target practice.
(horrific screams in the distance)
And what the Hell's that? Screaming practice?"
-also from Land of the Dead

"Unfortunately, this was not enough to appease the bloodthirsty psychic vampires at Limitless Horizons Entertainment LLC, and they launched after us like a cruise missile once somebody literate read to them what we had to say about their game." - Something Awful article, http:///articles.php?a=2706

My preferred fanfic pairings are unusual. I like redheads and troublemakers, not the goody-goody sissy girls; and those yaoi fangirls can burn in hell, writing 75 percent of all males to be flaming gay and teaching me that there is such a word as "twincest."
Inuyasha: Sesshoumaru/Kagome (or sometimes Kagura or Ayame)
Naruto: Naru w/Tema Ino Tayuya ; (Itachi is awesome with them too )
WITCH: Phobos/Will or Caleb/Will, ; Elyon's okay, I hate Cornelia
Danny Phantom: Danny/Ember, I guess Danny/Danielle
Ben10: Ben/Charm
Teen Titans: Robin/Raven (they're both dark. I liked Starfire, but she gets so damn annoying)
also Robin/Jinx or Blackfire/Robin (both girls are literally evil)
GW: Heero/Hilde (such a good pairing, rarely seen) or Quatre/Dorothy
Hellsing: Alucard/Seras (they actually SHRUNK her chest for the anime, if you can believe it)
Eva: Shinji/Asuka, Hikari or Maya Ibuki are OK (I dislike Rei)
Psychic Academy: Ai/Myuu (hate the other, sissy girl)
Ranma: (Ranma or Ryoga) with (Nabiki or Ukyo) (I hate Akane, Nabiki changing is more likely)
Fushigi Yuugi: Yui/Suboshi (Miaka is so painfully stupid, and Tamahome catches it) (Yui is so good at evil)
Megami Kouhousei: Zero/Kizuna (who can resist chicks with cat ears)
DBZ: Vegeta/Bulma (not that I can stand to watch the show)
Pokemon: Ash/Misty
Samurai Deeper Kyo: Kyo/Yuya (although Benitora is cool, Kyo wins. Damn is he cool.)
FMA: Ed/Riza, or Ed and Rose or Maria Ross (Al is so dumb)
FLCL: Naota/Haruko (Haruharu or Raharl, whatever you want to call her)
Cowboy Bebop: Vicious/Faye
Tenchi: Tenchi/Ryouko (damn do I hate Ayeka)
Escaflowne: Dilandau/Hitomi (though Merle is OK too)
Invader Zim: Zim/Gaz