I don't pull punches. If I think your story sucks, I'll say so. If I think it rocks, I'll say that as well. And sometimes I'll even suggest a few things to make it a better story if Ifeel that you've got a good handle of the characters and a promising plot.
I swear, it's just the way I am. I also know what the Hell I'm talking about. I write as well. I've got several stories published here. I've received good reviews, bad reviews, constructive criticism, and plenty of flames.
Why, you might ask, if I've published stories on here, am I not giving you my screenname? Because I don't want you flaming my stories solely in retaliation of the review I've given to you. If you've read my stories and come to the independent conclusion that they deserve a bad review or a flame, that's your right. I've never given a bad review to someone solely because they gave a bad review to me; I never will.
I'm also a stickler for the rules. If you break any of the elements of FF.net's TOS, I'll not only call you on it, I'll report you to the administration. The TOS are there for a reason; follow them.